Community Web Version Now Available
Lily
Practice for 11/12 你要做多少个作业？ 你阅读我提了的书了吗？ How much homework do you need to do? Did you read the book I mentioned? I am particularly concerned about my placement of 了 in the second sentence - a source I use to study with said that with 吗 it is placed near the end like that, but I would have put it after 读。谢谢你们 :)
Nov 22, 2020 7:48 AM
22
0
Corrections · 22
Practice for 11/12 你(需)要做多少作业？ 你(阅)读了我提到的书了吗？ How much homework do you need to do? Did you read the book I mentioned? I am particularly concerned about my placement of 了 in the second sentence - a source I use to study with said that with 吗 it is placed near the end like that, but I would have put it after 读。谢谢你们 :) because you use past tense, it should be 阅读了. also the latter is 提到了. actually, in my option, the second also is 你 看/读 过我提到的那本书了吗？
7 days ago
Practice for 11/12 你要做多少个作业？ A:你要坐多少作业 B:你有多少作业要做 I don't agree George's explanation, as far as I know, there are no concepts about countable noun and uncountable noun. Sometimes we can use both: 多少+noun 多少+ measure word+noun ex: 你有多少钱？ 你有多少块钱？ are both OK 你有多少水？ 你有多少瓶水？ 你有多少公斤水？ are all OK 水 and 钱 are both uncountable in English Why we ask 你有多少作业? is not because homework is uncountable, it because we don't know how to pick the measure word. the answer of "你有多少作业?" might be 我有一(篇)作文和三(道)数学题。 You see, there are two different measure word. we don't know the type of homework, then we don't know how to pick the measure word, then we just omitted it. 你阅读我提了的书了吗？ first: most of time, we put 了 after verb. second:阅读and提are both happened in the past. so 你阅读了我提了的书吗？ usually we don't use two 了s in one sentence so we usually have to option 1.The main question is you have read it or not. so the 了 after 阅读 cannot be omitted. we just omitted the second. 你阅读了我推荐的书吗？ 2. we replace the second 了 with another word. 你阅读了我推荐过的书吗？ How much homework do you need to do? Did you read the book I mentioned? I am particularly concerned about my placement of 了 in the second sentence - a source I use to study with said that with 吗 it is placed near the end like that, but I would have put it after 读。谢谢你们 :)
7 days ago
Practice for 11/12 你需要做多少作业？ (need=需要)你读我上次提到的书了吗？（我上次提到的书，你读了么？） How much homework do you need to do? Did you read the book I mentioned? I am particularly concerned about my placement of 了 in the second sentence - a source I use to study with said that with 吗 it is placed near the end like that, but I would have put it after 读。谢谢你们 :)
7 days ago
Practice for 11/12 你要做多少个作业？ 你阅读我提了的书了吗？ How much homework do you need to do? Did you read the book I mentioned? I am particularly concerned about my placement of 了 in the second sentence - a source I use to study with said that with 吗 it is placed near the end like that, but I would have put it after 读。谢谢你们 :)
7 days ago
Practice for 11/12 你要做多少份作业？ 你阅读了我提及过的书了吗？ How much homework do you need to do? Did you read the book I mentioned? I am particularly concerned about my placement of 了 in the second sentence - a source I use to study with said that with 吗 it is placed near the end like that, but I would have put it after 读。谢谢你们 :)
7 days ago