Check out our updated Community
Teacher Paul
Professional Teacher
"How are you?"..."err I am good thanks, no wait, I am well thanks, no wait....."
So I got into a big old debate about this topic with some English teachers (non-native) who had been taught that absolutely under no circumstances should we say "I am good" because we all know we need to use an adverb to modify a verb...blah blah blah....WRONG! But I did begin to doubt myself! So I researched and found / stole this explanation which works well...But in summary, the answer is "I am GOOD!"

The below is courtesy of https://mcelroytutoring.com/

"Don’t worry; if you’re one of the many people who says “I am well” and/or “I feel differently” (both incorrect) during normal conversation, then I won’t feel good (yes, James Brown had it right all along!) about correcting you. ; )

First of all, let’s define the verb “to be" (I am, you are, she is, etc.). Yes, it is a verb, but it is not an action verb; instead it is a verb that indicates a state of being, better known as a linking verb.

For linking verbs that indicate states of being, such as “to be” and “to feel”, we should NOT use adverbs (such as "well" and "differently") to modify them. Instead we should use adjectives, to describe ourselves (people are nouns) instead of the verb itself. That’s why we say “I am hungry” instead of “I am hungrily” and “I feel happy” instead of “I feel happily.”

Another issue with the verb “to feel” is that it has another, more literal definition: to touch with your hands. If I use an adverb next to the verb “feel,” then it suggests this more literal definition of the verb.

Thus, you should not say “I feel differently” unless you are, for example, referring to your different style of reading braille. And you should not say “I do not feel well” unless you are specifically referencing an illness (or lack thereof), in which case "well" would be used not as an adverb, but as an adjective (well vs. unwell).

To summarize:

I feel well = incorrect unless specifically referencing a prior illness
I feel good = correct
I am feeling well = incorrect unless specifically referencing an illness
I am feeling good = correct

I am well = incorrect unless specifically referencing an illness
I am good = correct
I am doing well = correct

I feel differently = incorrect
I feel different = correct

Other examples of linking verbs (also known as intransitive linking verbs) that should be modified by adjectives instead of adverbs:

to seem
to appear
to grow (old, wise, weary, etc.)
to look
to remain
to sound
to stay
to taste"
May 20, 2020 7:18 PM
Comments · 3
Many thanks for this discussion.
May 21, 2020
.
July 24, 2020
I would like to know your thoughts and other peoples thoughts on "I do not fell well" referencing you do not fell that you are well that is to say healthy. Unwell = unhealthy.
The very notion of well = healthy is apparently rooted deep into the English language and psyche. The phrase or word nowadays "welcome" derives from come healthy dating back to it's Germanic origins.
May 21, 2020
Teacher Paul
Language Skills
English, Spanish
Learning Language
Spanish