Chino Alpha
What does the underlined part imply? The snow was coming, and when it did, any poor options he had would be abrogated. And after the snow, what? What then, when they were shut in and at the mercy of whatever _might have_ only been toying with them before. Source: The Shining Hi. I don't understand why "might have" is used here. It doesn't seem like a 3rd conditional. It seems to imply a mini dialogue: A: What might been only been toying with them before? B: It might have been ghosts or other paranormal force. I mention "paranormal force" because in this novel, the Torrances (family) did suffer from paranormal force before. Is my thinking right? Thank you.
Nov 21, 2017 7:53 AM
Answers · 4
You're right, not the 3rd conditional- it's a past modal of deduction (may/might/could/must + have +past participle(V3)), used to speculate about something in the past. The question is not whether the forces toying with them were paranormal (it is assumed or known that they were paranormal) but rather that the acts of those forces were possibly not yet serious or dangerous, with the implication that they soon would be. The forces might have been toying with them-- the paranormal forces might have been teasing them, or trying to scare them. Since might is not certain, it means that other possibilities exist, like it was just a random occurrence , or, (more likely, because it's Stephen King), that it was the beginning of something more serious than 'toying' A more concrete example: LOUD NOISE Speaker A: What was that? Speaker B: It might have been a ghost! Speaker C:It could have been a bomb! Speaker D: Don't be silly, it must have been a noise from the machines at the building site across the street". i.e while B and C were possible (might/could), D is much more likely and therefore we use 'must' to say that we believe this is the most likely probability.
November 21, 2017
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Chino Alpha
Language Skills
Chinese (Mandarin), English, Japanese
Learning Language
English, Japanese