Kseniia
Any difference? It's a rather silly question. It's rather a silly question. Is there any difference between these two sentences? If yes, what is it?
Oct 28, 2019 3:22 PM
Answers · 9
In "a rather silly question", the 'rather' is modifying 'silly'; in "rather a silly question", the 'rather' is modifying 'a silly question'. There isn't a discernable difference in meaning. However, there are cases where you would choose one construction over the other: With any determiner other than 'a/an', the 'rather' has to come before the adjective: for example, "You asked some rather silly questions" or "She wore that rather risqué dress". The 'rather' in first position option isn't possible here. However, it's more usual to say "You took rather a long time" than "You took a rather long time", but I don't really know why. The first feels more natural: perhaps because 'a long time' is seen as a fixed concept? I'm not sure, though.
October 29, 2019
To me, as an American, the word "rather" already feels both old-fashioned and British, but "rather a" feels MORE old-fashioned and MORE British than "a rather." As an American, I'd usually use words like slightly, somewhat, fairly, or kind of. Google Ngrams shows the begfore 1905 in America, and before 1930 in England, "rather a" was more common than "a rather". Now, i both countries, "a rather" is much more common than "rather a". But, as everyone else said, the difference is very small.
October 28, 2019
There is no significant difference.
October 28, 2019
Thank you Trang Thuỳ, thank you Tyler!
October 28, 2019
There is really no difference between these two sentences. The difference in tone is SO minimal, that it would be hard to put it into words.
October 28, 2019
Show More
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Kseniia
Language Skills
English, Gaelic (Irish), Russian
Learning Language
English, Gaelic (Irish)