Pelin
Which one is OK? He is sick. In this case, he can't go on a journey. In this state, he can't go on a journey.
4 de jan de 2024 13:17
Respostas · 5
1
Both are correct. In this case = the entire situation - in the case that he is sick. In this state = his state or condition - the state = sickness
4 de janeiro de 2024
A conversation could go something like... Person 1: "He's sick" Person 2: "In THAT case, he can't travel" Person 1: "No, not in this state"
5 de janeiro de 2024
Natural is: In his condition, he can’t travel. (‘this’ instead of ‘his’ requires his ill condition be obvious in front of of the speaker) Also possible: A: Jim’s running a fever and vomiting. B: In that case, he can’t travel. I suppose it could be theoretically possible to be well enough to travel but too sick to “go on a journey” but it’s not a very clear way of speaking since ‘going on a journey’ is rare.
5 de janeiro de 2024
Take this from an native English speaker, in this state, is the correct choice option, try not to over think it, he is sick, is the only context needed to know that he is not in the best state to go on a journey. In this case, is not the correct answer as it goes over the rest of the sentence as if there was more to be said. Again don't over think it, you'll get the hang of it
5 de janeiro de 2024
The first sentence is a bit unnatural; something like, “In that case, he can’t travel.” Although you could use the phrase, “on a journey,” this would be more literary/poetic, rather than conversational. Regarding the second sentence, it would be much more natural to say something like, “He can’t travel in this/that state.”
5 de janeiro de 2024
Ainda não encontrou suas respostas?
Escreva suas perguntas e deixe os falantes nativos ajudá-lo!