Pesquise entre vários professores de Inglês...
Martin
Someone (a politician who is a native speaker of English) has said the following recently: "She´s OF a place where she wouldn´t know what a better job is". My question has to do with the preposition he used ("of" - to be of a place...). Is that correct? I thought that the correct preposition in this case would be "from" - to be FROM a place. Can anyone tell me what the correct way of saying this would be? Thanks!!!

Respostas · 7

2
Of course "from a place" is a much more common collocation, but that doesn't automatically make "of a place" grammatically incorrect. It could be an effective way to express the thought more poetically. If it was part of a speech, it may have been a deliberate choice that the speaker deployed to make the words sound more dramatic. If it was just in conversation, it was certainly an unusual choice of words; but that doesn't necessarily make it incorrect.
0
Yes, you're right! The more common and standard preposition is "from" when referring to someone's origin or where they come from, as in "She’s from a place where she wouldn’t know what a better job is." "Of" vs. "From": * "From": Refers to a person's origin or where they are geographically or culturally linked to. * Example: "She’s from a small town." * "Of": Can sometimes be used to describe a deeper, more intrinsic connection to a place, but it’s less common in everyday speech and can sound poetic or formal. * Example: "She is of noble heritage." Summary: * Correct Phrase: "She’s from a place where she wouldn’t know what a better job is." * "Of" can work, but "from" is standard and more appropriate in this context.
0
‘of’ conveys a closer connection and the idea that the place has affected the person. In this case it’s a little redundant because the author explains explicitly that the result is a lack of awareness of the existence of better jobs. Saying ‘from’ here would work well and convey the same meaning. ‘She’s a woman of a poor town and happy with her low-paying job.’ (An example where the author uses ‘of’ to imply a general point)
0
I agree with Jonathan and Chris. OF a place is more poetic, more about a mental state perhaps. It made me think of being IN a place too > referring to one's mental state or perhaps societal level.

Ainda não encontrou suas respostas?

Escreva suas perguntas e deixe os falantes nativos ajudá-lo!

Não perca a oportunidade de aprender uma língua no conforto da sua casa. Navegue pela nossa seleção de professores de línguas experientes e inscreva-se na sua primeira aula agora mesmo!

Comece a aprender hoje