Jessicamessica
Hello! Could you help me with this one? Which one is correct? 73 A lot ________ to the house before we can move in. needs be doing needs done needs doing needs to do
10 de dez de 2023 08:27
Respostas · 5
2
1) The third choice is correct. 2) I personally think "needs to be done" would be better than any of them. 3) Oddly enough, I think "needs done" would be characteristic of the US region of Pittsburgh and western Pennsylvania. It is a characteristic of a variety of English influenced by "Pennsylvania Dutch," a dialect of that region.
11 de dezembro de 2023
2
The third choice is the only one that works grammatically. It is somewhat confusing (for reasons I will explain below), but people do talk this way and it will be easily understood. Let's analyze it. It is a compound sentence, composed of two independent clauses joined by the conjunction "before". Since the meaning of "before we can move in" is clear, we can ignore that clause and just concentrate the first clause, "A lot needs doing to the house": SUBJECT: "A lot" VERB: "needs" DIRECT OBJECT: "doing" (present participle acting as a noun) SUBORDINATE CLAUSE: "to the house" "A lot" here means "a lot of work" or "much work". Even if you don't say the word "work", it is implicit. "Work" doesn't need to be said because the speaker's intent is obvious. However, the sentence is easier for us to analyze if we replace "A lot" with "Much work": "Much work needs doing to the house". When we rephrase the sentence this way, its awkwardness becomes more glaring. It becomes clear that "to" is not the best preposition. We can construct more natural sentences using "for", "on", or "with". You could tie the clause closer to "work" by moving the clause to the beginning of the sentence: "For the house, much work needs doing." Now that we understand what's going on, we can put "a lot" back in: "For the house, a lot needs doing." I think this is an improvement. The original sentence with "to the house" was confusing because the clause "to the house" was trying to play multiple roles. On the one hand it was trying to be the object of the present participle "doing". At the same time it was trying to modify the unspoken word "work" or the spoken word "lot".
10 de dezembro de 2023
1
I would like to add that none of these choices are very good in my opinion. The most natural way to say this would be? NEEDS TO BE DONE
11 de dezembro de 2023
1
Needs doing Please message me if you’d like an explanation. I think it’s important students don’t only ask for answers but try to work out the thought process behind them too
10 de dezembro de 2023
Ainda não encontrou suas respostas?
Escreva suas perguntas e deixe os falantes nativos ajudá-lo!