Heidi
Is it natural to say 'What do you get as a birthday present?'? Or is it better to say 'what birthday presents do you get?'? If they're both not that good, I hope you can show me some more common way to express what I'd like to express. Thank you!!
6 de out de 2015 13:29
Respostas · 14
1
Hello Helen, As you are talking about something that has already happened, I would say 'What did you get for your birthday.' It is more natural than your questions. Hope this helps Bob
6 de outubro de 2015
I would answer the same as Bob. Usually such a question is the past tense. However, if you were to ask the class in a discussion, then the following will sound more natural. "what (sort of) birthday presents do you get when it is your birthday?"
6 de outubro de 2015
Usually they don't know what presents they are going to get. But if they do; "What (presents) are you getting for your birthday?" It is strange to ask someone what they are going to get. ^^ That's why it would past tense. "What did you get for your birthday?" But I understand your students are learning in the present tense first?
6 de outubro de 2015
Thank you all!!
7 de outubro de 2015
I think it is more natural to say like that :What would you like for your birthday
6 de outubro de 2015
Mostrar mais
Ainda não encontrou suas respostas?
Escreva suas perguntas e deixe os falantes nativos ajudá-lo!