Pesquise entre vários professores de Inglês...
Melissa
Professor ProfissionalDifference between 아/어/여 봤어요, 본 적이 있어요, and 적이 있어요?
As I understand, these three different structures kind of allude to the present perfect, but I don't understand how they're different. For example:
한국에 가 봤어요 - I've been to Korea
한국에 가 본 적이 있어요 - I've been to Korea
한국에 가 적이 있어요 - I've been to Korea
Is this correct? If so, how are these structures different?
19 de jul de 2018 20:27
Respostas · 1
1
1. 한국에 가 봤어요.
2. 한국에 가 본 적이 있어요.
3. 한국에 간 적이 있어요. (가 적이 -> 간 적이)
(After the correction on #3) They all state a past experience as your translation says.
Korean past tense by itself (like 갔다 in predicative, and 간 in attributive adjective form) represents either a simple past action or present perfect in the sense of completion. So 그 사람은 갔어요 would mean "He went" or "He has gone", and never anything about experience.
-아/어/여 보다 is a helper verb that adds the meaning of doing something for trial or test. Its past past tense (가 봤다) denotes that the speaker has had certain experience, as in your #1 example.
-(으)ㄴ 적이 있다 ("There was a time I ...") literally states you had certain experience in the past. So it can be used like the English present perfect about past experience. Your #3 sentence is a case of this.
#2 is combining both phrases in one sentence (which is often done in real usage), so it has the clearest sense of the three.
Generally, -아/어/여 보다 has a lighter feel and is often used to ask about interesting experience, while -(으)ㄴ 적이 있다 is more often about straight facts.
For example,
- 한국 음식 먹어 봤어요? / 먹어 본 적(이) 있어요? Have you ever tried Korean food?
- 5월 25일 이후에 피해자을 만난 적이 있습니까? Have you ever met the victim since May 25?
19 de julho de 2018
Ainda não encontrou suas respostas?
Escreva suas perguntas e deixe os falantes nativos ajudá-lo!
Melissa
Habilidades linguísticas
Árabe, Chinês (Mandarim), Holandês, Inglês, Francês, Japonês, Coreano, Espanhol
Idioma de aprendizado
Árabe, Chinês (Mandarim), Holandês, Francês, Japonês, Coreano, Espanhol
Artigos que Você Pode Gostar Também

Same Word, Different Meaning: American, British, and South African English
23 votados positivos · 17 Comentários

How to Sound Confident in English (Even When You’re Nervous)
19 votados positivos · 13 Comentários

Marketing Vocabulary and Phrases for Business English Learners
16 votados positivos · 6 Comentários
Mais artigos
