Question about could
Hi.
I learned that we can use 'could' and 'can' to talk about possible actions now or in the future.
and we can also use 'could' (not can) to say that something (a situation or happening) is possible now or in the future.
A: If you're hungry, we can have dinner now. -> this is possible action so I can replace can to could
B: I need to borrow a camera. - You can borrow mine. -> the answer sheet says I also can use 'could'.
C: Be careful climbing that tree. You can fall. -> 'could' only. Here I have a question. Isn't falling a possible action?
Could you help me to understand how to distinguish between possible action and something is possible?
Thank you.
Pesquise entre vários professores de Inglês...
Respostas · 4
0
Remember that the word 'possible' has several different meanings. These sentences demonstrate the difference between 'allowed', 'feasible' and 'potential'.
The first two can use 'can' because there is an element of choice involved. In the first two situations, the action is 'possible' in that it is ALLOWED and/or FEASIBLE: the person can choose to have dinner now or later, or to borrow the camera or not. The speaker is saying that these two actions are options. The person has the option of eating early or borrowing the camera if they wish to.
In the third example, falling from the tree is not an 'option' - it is something that might happen, whether the person wants it or not. This is a very different scenario, where the word 'possible' refers to a POTENTIAL consequence. This why you can't use 'can' here.
0
Can is used with ordinary mood while could is a subjunctive form of "can".
The first one is in the subjunctive.
The second one could be indicative or in the subjunctive, depending on how you expand the "I need to borrow a camera" part, "I need to borrow a camera because I am going to work" (the indicative mood), or "I need to borrow a camera if I am doing a project of my own" (the subjunctive mood).
"You could fall and break your neck" - here, it's clearly the subjunctive mood.
0
Think you should wait for an actual English teacher to answer this before you take my advice to heart but...
In most situations, "could" implies multiple options.
For example, when I say "You can eat," that usually means you're able to eat now. If I say "You could eat" it is usually followed by an "or".
For example, "You could eat, or you could stay in your room."
Again, you should wait for an English teacher to answer, but as a native English speaker that is generally how I use it.
Hope this helps
Ainda não encontrou suas respostas?
Escreva suas perguntas e deixe os falantes nativos ajudá-lo!
Não perca a oportunidade de aprender uma língua no conforto da sua casa. Navegue pela nossa seleção de professores de línguas experientes e inscreva-se na sua primeira aula agora mesmo!
Comece a aprender hoje
