Sally
Do you think is it a good way to improve English listening by TED without subtitles ? When I listen to TED , there are many unfamiliar words and expressions . If I don't look up it in dictionary or watching subtitles , I can not understand what they say . Should I stop listen to make clear ?Or continue listen and ignore those problems ?
29 Ara 2017 04:58
Yorumlar · 8
8

I think English subtitles can be very helpful at first-- it is like working on reading and listening at the same time.  Later, when you find there are only a few words you do not know, then working on listening by itself can be good. That is my advice if you only want to listen to something once.  

However, I think it is also helpful to listen to a video twice or even three times.-  I listen once just listening with no subtitles and no looking up, and listen another time looking everything up. (And sometimes a third time with no subtitels again.)   I am undecided which I think is better to do first and I tried but have been unable to find research on it.  I believe when I do not use subtitles I pay more attention to the faces and mouths of people and my brain also works hard just on paying more attention to the sounds and the meanings.  

Your brain learns from comprehensible input.  At the level I am at now, I can understand the vast majority of what I hear without subtitles, so when I do hear a word that is unfamiliar to me I can make a mental note of it and sometimes understand it just from the context-- learning it more like a child would.  At earlier levels, adults can use the language they already know as an aid to make it comprehensible. 

29 Aralık 2017
4
Even as a native English speaker, I would definitely stop the Ted Talk whenever the speaker says a word that I don't know to go research it's meaning. How else can you truly learn technical words without researching their meaning? Alot of the time the vocabulary these speakers use is not obvious and is very technical.
29 Aralık 2017
2
Thank you Ronen, I feel the same Sally. When I'm interested in the topic, I can understand what she/he says. Otherwise I don't get it at all. I put them in my walkman and listened over and over again, but it didn't work. I quit downloading TEDTALK anymore. Now I'm learning using "Friends". I recommend to watch it with no subtitles first, then with subtitiles in English and with subtitiles in your mother tongue for the third time. I can understand the feeling every line contains in my native language. That's my "aha" moment. After that  I speak every line out loud myself. It makes my speaking ability improve, I believe. Good luck!
29 Aralık 2017
1
Initially,  You should listen or read about the topic in which you have a interest and then look for other topics
29 Aralık 2017
1
your problem same with me
29 Aralık 2017
Daha fazla göster