Çeşitli İngilizce öğretmenleri arasından arama yapın...
Dan Smith
Rewiring my brain to "believe" in grammatical gender?

I've been studying Spanish for several years now, but I still continue to make frequent mistakes in gender agreement. I've gotten past the stage of being confused by "la mano" or "el tema" or "el agua," I understand that not all masculine nouns end in -o and not all feminine nouns end in -a.

The problem is that whenever I let my attention flag--if I am trying to get a verb tense right, for example--I make mistakes elsewhere in the sentence, particularly on gender agreement. And I mean the stupidest mistakes, like "las gatos" or "los montañas."

Does anyone have any specific suggestions on how to rewire an English-speaking brain so that the "language" parts of it truly believe that words really do have gender and that articles, adjectives, and nouns really need to agree? Do you know any specific exercises or drills to deal with this specific problem?

27 Oca 2019 17:51
Yorumlar · 16
4

I found it extremely useful to always learn a noun together with the article or any other word indicating the grammatical gender.

So, e.g. the cat is le chat (masc.) in French and die Katze (fem.) in German. This is a typical case where learners mix up grammatical genders, but this only happens when they learn the wrong way at school i.e. remember cat=chat=Katze and remember the gender as a separate element. While speaking you just don't have enough time to check and doublecheck all this gender stuff and put the part together in a correct way. At least it will take you quite a long time. But when you learn it as a set, then in your head it is le chat / un chat resp. die Katze / eine Katze. Just accept chat to be a "le"-word and Katze to be a "die"-word and the gender question will not even pop up.

What can you do for languages which have gender but no article, like Russian or Hindi? In Russian you might add an adjective such as хороший/хорошая/хорошее and in Hindi you could use the or particles actually used for possessive but always indicating the right gender...


[edited for typos]


27 Ocak 2019
3
Hi, Dan. In regards to remembering the gender, Rüdiger’s suggestion is the usual SOP — all students should absolutely use it from day 1, and it should work if done with the right mental state. (Everything in language learning is mental.) So my question is, did you or did you not learn every Spanish noun with its article? If you’ve tried that and it still didn’t work, then we’ll need to come up with some more creative options, preferably based on what’s going on inside your own brain.

As far as exercises, there’s no one-size-fits-all approach, but I’m going to suggest you go back to your exercises for the third-person unstressed direct object pronouns (lo, los, la, las) and do them orally, with 100% focus, as slowly as you need to to achieve 100% accuracy. Do not practice mistakes. Here’s one example, but there are many different exercises you could do:


One more thing to think about — English does have grammatical gender for human beings, and I’ll bet you almost never get the pronoun wrong.

ESL learners: It’s OK, even preferable, to refer to animals as “he” or “she” if you know their biological gender. It’s definitely preferable to refer to babies as “he” or “she”, even though the neuter gender is grammatically acceptable. Strangely, German uses neuter gender to refer to a child, even when his or her gender is known (das Kind).
27 Ocak 2019
3
I still haven't managed to rewrite my brain to believe that English words DON'T have gender. Especially when it comes to animals. It still feels super awkward to call an animal "it" so eventually I simply decided not to do it even though I know that I should. With time and practice though, you will make fewer mistakes.
27 Ocak 2019
2

Actually, English speakers also find it strange to refer to an animal as 'it', particularly if it is a pet or a familiar farm animal.  The gender of a pet will be known to its owner, and others will most likely assign it an arbitrary gender sooner than refer to it as 'it'.

'Him' or 'her', 'he' or 'she' personalises an animal, and most of us will do this if given a chance.  Of course, less appealing, or less well-known creatures are also less likely to be accorded an honorary gender.

27 Ocak 2019
1
Hi, Dan

I happened upon this thread today, and I'm glad I did. I agree with Phil's comments and suggestions. Have you found an Italki professor who corrects you 'immediately and unequivocally'? I'm finding that most teachers are reluctant to do this for some reason. Any referrals would be appreciated.

Thanks
19 Mart 2020
Daha fazla göster

Evden çıkmadan dil öğrenme fırsatını kaçırmayın. Deneyimli dil eğitmenlerimizden oluşan seçkimize göz atın ve ilk dersinize şimdi kaydolun!