Sasha
Profesyonel Öğretmen
What happens with the phrase "so far" in the indirect speech? Does it change into until then or smth “My new house is supposed to be haunted, but so far I haven’t seen any ghosts,” she said. She said that her new house was supposed to be haunted, but until then she hadn’t seen any ghosts.
21 Nis 2013 15:06
Yanıtlar · 4
1
I think what's actually changing in this sentence is not direct/indirect, but present/past. Present - "My new house is supposed to be haunted, but I so far haven't seen any ghosts." Present - "She says here new house is supposed to be haunted, but so far she hasn't seen any ghosts." Past - "My new house was supposed to be haunted, but until then I hadn't seen any ghosts." Past - "She said her new house was supposed to be haunted, but until then she hadn't seen any ghosts."
21 Nisan 2013
1
In addition to all the answers given above, you can also say: She said that her new house was supposed to be haunted, but she hadn’t seen any ghosts yet.
21 Nisan 2013
1
but that until then she hadn’t seen any ghosts but that till then she hadn’t seen any ghosts but that so far she hadn’t seen any ghosts
21 Nisan 2013
Hâlâ cevap bulamadın mı?
Sorularını yaz ve ana dil konuşanlar sana yardım etsin!