[Kullanıcı Silindi]
Had been + went I had been to Spain to study Spanish for a year and I am still studying it today. Additionally, I have also taken up German study and would like to practice speaking with native speakers. In the above sentence, is it more natural / correct to use 'I went to Spain' (I would never use (had been to) in the above case) or does it depend on the time as in, 'I went to Spain last year' or ' I had been to Spain ten years ago'? Please note that I am no longer living in Spain now. Thank you in advance.
3 Tem 2018 23:11
Yanıtlar · 10
3
Simple past I went to Spain for a year. (Happened sometime in the past, I am no longer there) Present perfect I have been in Spain for a year. (I have been living in Spain for a year and I am still living in Spain) Past perfect I had been in Spain for a year before I got sick. (I was in Spain some time ago for a year before another event in the past - getting sick)
4 Temmuz 2018
3
Yes, "had been to" is unnatural in the sentence. You are correct that "I went to Spain to study Spanish for a year and am still studying it today." is better. The past perfect ("had been to") is unnatural without a reference to another event in the past ("I had been to Spain twice before [my last trip].") If you want to talk about a specific time it is good to use the past tense ("I went to Spain last year."), and the amount of time generally doesn't matter ("John went to Spain ten years ago." "John went to the store a few minutes ago."). If the time is indefinite, you can use the present perfect ("I have been to Spain many times over the years.")
3 Temmuz 2018
Understand. See my comments below my answer below. Cheers!
4 Temmuz 2018
Hello kenneth, thank you again. No, I wish to indicate that I am not in Spain any longer but am still studying Spanish today.
4 Temmuz 2018
Just to be clear. Do you mean in the following sentence that you are still in Spain studying? "I had been to Spain to study Spanish for a year and I am still studying it today."
4 Temmuz 2018
Hâlâ cevap bulamadın mı?
Sorularını yaz ve ana dil konuşanlar sana yardım etsin!