Who is/am
Hi, there
Which of these sentences is right?
"You have to be more kind to people, especially to me, who IS your brother" or "You have to be more kind to people, especially to me, who AM your brother"?
"A lot of people would prefer to get books for their birthday, especially me, who IS/AM a voracious reader"?
Thank you
Çeşitli İngilizce öğretmenleri arasından arama yapın...
Yanıtlar · 10
2
Regardless of grammatical correctness or incorrectness, I think the most important point here is that no native speaker of English would ever say either one of these sentences. We would ALWAYS rephrase the sentence to avoid using "who is" or "who am," because they both sound extremely wrong.
Unless the pronoun is in the nominative case (I, he, she), English almost never uses the construction "[pronoun], who [is/am/are]..." It may be correct to say, "Give it to him, who is your brother," but it sounds very weird. As others have said, any native speaker would rewrite the sentence to say something like, "Give it to him, your brother" / "Give it to him, as your brother" / "Give it to him, since he's your brother."
We would be even less likely to use a "[pronoun], who [is]" structure for first- or second-person pronouns. It will sound wrong no matter what verb you choose.
2
They aren’t correct because in this case using “who is” and especially “who am” is not a grammatically correct. The correct form is “You have to be more kind to people, especially to me, AS your brother.”.
“A lot of people would prefer to get books for their birthday, especially me, AS a voracious reader.”. :)
1
I would rewrite it like this.
"You need to be kinder to people, especially to me, who is your brother" or
"You have to be kinder to people, especially to me, [after all] I am your brother"?
"You have to be kinder to people, especially to me, your brother"?
"A lot of people would prefer to get books for their birthday, especially me, [I am] a voracious reader"?
[ these words are optional]
There is nothing ungrammatical with "who is" or "I am"
0
So, this is an interesting question for which the answer is a bit complex. Although it sounds awkward to most ears, using 'am' is correct. Generally speaking, the verb of a clause has to agree with the person of the subject, and where the subject of a clause is a pronoun, it would have to agree with the pronoun's antecedent or referent. So, me refers to I, so, I AM your brother. Same for both sentences. However, that is strictly grammatical, following the logic of established rules and we all know that language often doesn't play nicely with the rules. In terms of what is in common usage - IS is more frequently used nowadays.
There are very detailed answers here:
https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/28662/what-rules-make-remember-me-who-am-your-friend-grammatical
And here: https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/362949/me-who-is-or-me-who-am
0
Could I say “A lot of people would prefer to get books for their birthday, especially me, as I am a voracious reader"?
Hâlâ cevap bulamadın mı?
Sorularını yaz ve ana dil konuşanlar sana yardım etsin!
Evden çıkmadan dil öğrenme fırsatını kaçırmayın. Deneyimli dil eğitmenlerimizden oluşan seçkimize göz atın ve ilk dersinize şimdi kaydolun!
Bugün öğrenmeye başlayın
