Jênisson (Aeneas)
Gerund - Grammar I read that when a verb is the subject of the sentence it must be gerund, is it right? I have this doubt because I saw on a book the ensuing phrase: "to listen is to receive" where the verb "to listen" is subject, is it miswritten?
10 Şub 2011 16:48
Yanıtlar · 4
3
1. When a verb becomes a noun, be it subject or object, you use the gerund. This is the rule and it is correct. 2. To your example: the infinitive can be used with the verb "mean", or any other like expression. To listen is to receive. = To listen means to receive. The reason for this is a little complicated. The phrase "to listen" is taken as an idea, and has become the subject in front of the verb "is".
10 Şubat 2011
1
its wrong saying. in the sentence "to listen is to receive" - to listen functions as a subject expressed by the infinitive. its not a gerund.
10 Şubat 2011
A gerund always ends in "ing" Check out defintion 2 on this site: http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/gerund We have more than one "verbal" in the English language that can be used as a different part of speech. In your case, you use "to listen." This is an infinitive. Infinitives can also be a subject as it is in your example. To use gerunds in your sentence, you would say, "Listening is receiving," in which case there are 2 gerunds: Listening and Receiving. Both are verbs, but end in "ing" and are used as nouns. That is the definition of a gerund.
10 Şubat 2011
Must be the gerund or "to verb"; ie, the "infinitives", not only subject, but also object. You need some concept called "entirety".
10 Şubat 2011
Hâlâ cevap bulamadın mı?
Sorularını yaz ve ana dil konuşanlar sana yardım etsin!