ابحث بين معلمي الإنجليزية المتعددين...

Disagreeing Politely in Malayalam — How to Argue and Keep the Room | Learn Malayalam #306
الوصف
How to disagree, complain and argue in Malayalam without losing the room. Every course teaches you to agree. Almost none teach you to disagree — and disagreement is where a foreign speaker actually gets into trouble, because the words are easy and the calibration is not.
Kerala argues, and argues well: near-universal literacy, the highest newspaper readership in India, and a culture where having a position is expected. You will be asked what you think about your own country's government in week two.
I am Dr. Reshmi R. Nair, an applied linguist from Kerala. I have taught hundreds of learners to speak Malayalam as it is actually spoken.
THE WORDS
അഭിപ്രായം (abhipraayam) - opinion
ചർച്ച (charcha) - discussion
വാദം (vaadam) - an argument, a case being made
തർക്കം (tharkkam) - a dispute
വിയോജിപ്പ് (viyojippu) - disagreement
സമ്മതം (sammatham) - agreement, consent
THE LADDER, SOFTEST TO HARDEST
എനിക്ക് ഉറപ്പില്ല (enikku urappilla) - I am not sure
എനിക്ക് ഒരു സംശയമുണ്ട് (enikku oru samshayamundu) - I have a doubt (in Indian English, a question)
ശരിയാണ്, പക്ഷേ (shariyaanu, pakshe) - that is true, but. The concession move: the most useful shape here.
എനിക്ക് തോന്നുന്നത് ഇങ്ങനെയാണ് (enikku thonnunnathu inganeyaanu) - what it seems to me is this
തോന്നുക (thonnuka) - to seem, to feel; the standard way to hedge an opinion
അങ്ങനെ അല്ല (angane alla) - it is not like that
എനിക്ക് വിയോജിപ്പുണ്ട് (enikku viyojippundu) - I disagree
അത് ശരിയല്ല (athu shariyalla) - that is not correct. Fine among friends, rude to a stranger.
THE THING NO TEXTBOOK TELLS YOU
In Malayalam, anger is often signalled by an INCREASE in politeness. If a friend who always used നീ (nee) switches to നിങ്ങൾ (ningal), or starts calling you sar, you have not been promoted — you have been pushed away. A Malayali hears it instantly; a foreigner hears courtesy and keeps talking cheerfully into a wall.
Has this happened to you without your noticing? Tell me in the comments.
#LearnMalayalam #Malayalam #Kerala
قناة البث الصوتي
Malayalam Fluency Lab | Study Plans, Mistakes and Practice
المؤلف

