Please only native English speakers from the UK, USA, Canada, Australia answer my question. I cannot accept replies from non-native English tutors or speakers. Thank you for understanding.
Thank the native English speakers very much in advance.
1a. I shall write tomorrow.
1b. I will write tomorrow.
2a. Who will lend me a cigarette?
2b. Who shall lend me a cigarette?
3a. Very well, if you want to go, go you shall.
3b. Very well, if you want to go, go you should.
3c. Very well, if you want to go, you
should go.
3d. Very well, if you want to go, go you will.
Question:
Which is grammatically correct in each pair?
Do they have the same meaning in each pair?
ابحث بين معلمي الإنجليزية المتعددين...
الإجابات · 2
0
Hi Caxio. Did you know that in South Africa English is one of our offical languages? There are many native English speakers here. Just like Australia, we are post British colonial country.
To answer your questions:
Traditionally, British grammar taught that shall was used with I/we and will with you/he/she/they for the future. Today, will is used for all people and is the normal choice. Shall sounds formal, old-fashioned, or is used in specific phrases.
1a vs 1b: I shall write tomorrow vs I will write tomorrow
Both are correct and mean the same thing.
I will write tomorrow is natural, modern English.
I shall write tomorrow is very formal, old-fashioned, or literary.
2a vs 2b: Who will lend me a cigarette? vs Who shall lend me a cigarette?
Who will lend me a cigarette? is correct and natural.
Who shall lend me a cigarette? is grammatically possible, but sounds very old-fashioned and unnatural.
Today, shall is mainly used in questions like:
Shall we go?
Shall I help you?
3a–3d: go you shall / go you should / you should go / go you will
These use unusual word order for emphasis.
You should go is normal way to give advice.
Go you shall is dramatic or formal. It sounds like a command or a strong promise (“You will go.”)
Go you should is old-fashioned way of giving advice.
Go you will sounds like a prediction or a prophecy.
So in modern English, use:
will for the future
should for advice
shall mainly for offers, suggestions, or very formal writing.
Hope that helps
لم تجد إجاباتك بعد؟
اكتب اسألتك ودع الناطقين الأصليين باللغات يساعدونك!
لا تفوّت فرصة تعلّم لغة جديدة وأنت مرتاح في منزلك. تصفّح مجموعتنا المختارة من مدرّسي اللغات ذوي الخبرة وسجّل في درسك الأول الآن!
ابدأ التعلم اليوم
