mickey
How long have you been in xxx What is the exact meaning of this expression? When someone asked me A person:"How long have you been in Australia?" I: "3 weeks." A person:"No, until when are you going to stay?" I: Oh until.... I think 'How long have you been~" means on going thing. But, are you asking future staying? I am confused. How could I answer in this situation?
١٣ فبراير ٢٠١٨ ١٠:٠١
الإجابات · 7
1
I'm confused, too. Are you sure that the other person is a native speaker? Or, if they are, are you sure that you heard the first question correctly? If the other person isn't a native speaker, I can only presume that they were asking you the 'wrong' question - in other words, their first question wasn't what they meant to ask you. "How long have you been in Australia?" is asking you about the time from when you arrived in Australia until now. It's now the middle of February. So, if you arrived in Australia in late January, your answer is correct : Q: "How long have you been in Australia?" A: "I've been here 3 weeks". Is that correct? Have you really been in Australia since late January? Unless the other person knew that this was untrue, their response of "No" doesn't really make sense. The second question has a different meaning. If they'd wanted to ask about the total length of your stay, their first question should have been "How long are you in Australia for?"
١٣ فبراير ٢٠١٨
A person:"How long have you been in Australia?" I: "3 weeks." ..."I have been in Australia for 3 weeks" these are both perfect normal answers. The person should have asked... "How long are you going to stay in Aus..."or "How long are you staying in Aus...". Then you would answer something like "Until Christmas" or "another 2 months" or "Until I get homesick"...
١٣ فبراير ٢٠١٨
Ohhh, okay. It might be. I understand and thanks so much!
١٣ فبراير ٢٠١٨
If the question is "How long you have been in Australia?", then your reply is correct. It mean how long have you been staying in Australia. Maybe the person is asking "How long will you be staying in Australia?", then the answer should be until when you are staying.
١٣ فبراير ٢٠١٨
لم تجد إجاباتك بعد؟
اكتب اسألتك ودع الناطقين الأصليين باللغات يساعدونك!