Busca entre varios profesores de Inglés...
Jason
reflexive se and impersonal se

Señora, se le cayó la cartera a usted.

To my understanding, in this sentence, ‘se’ is the reflexive from ‘caerse’, and ‘le’ is the indirect object ‘usted’.

What if I want to replace the ‘la cartera’ to pronoun?<o:p></o:p>

Do I say: Señora, se se la cayó. ?? In which the second ‘se’ is the ‘usted’? 

This seems legit grammatically, but it’s really strange… 
27 de oct. de 2017 11:56
Comentarios · 3
"Señora, se le cayó su cartera" 
29 de octubre de 2017
What Grzybek said was correct. In your sentence, la cartera is the subject of the verb caerse (which is a pronominal verb, btw = so se is related to this verb as you did, right).

Then, if you can change a noun or nominal group by a pronoun like (la/lo/las/los), it should be the direct object (isn't the case).

To sum up... if you want to replace something in this sentence for a pronoun, it only could be a usted (no direct objetc) = le (which is on it and doubled by a usted)

Señora, se le cayó la cartera.

29 de octubre de 2017

Just thinking, I´m a student as yourself, but I´ll do my best...

You wouldn't change it for la nor le. It has a different function in this sentence. La cartera is a subject here. In order to change it for la/le it would have to be an object (direct/indirect). I suppose you could switch it for "ella" and say: "Ella se le cayó". (?)


27 de octubre de 2017

No pierdas la oportunidad de aprender un idioma desde la comodidad de tu casa. ¡Explora nuestra selección de profesores de idiomas con experiencia e inscríbete ya en tu primera clase!