yhemusa
Is a "common criminal" an "ordinary criminal" or a "notorious criminal"?
Is a "common criminal" an "ordinary criminal" or a "notorious criminal"? Are the two meanings equally often used in contemporary English?

I have several use examples as follows, is it possible to decide at the first sight/hearing which meaning is carried in each sentence without more context(and I actually do not have)?

1. He also berate Carter for inviting Soviet dissident Vladmir Bukovsky, whom he called " a common criminal", to the White House?

2. Because of one minor offence he was branded a common criminal.

3. The government insisted he was a common criminal.

4. A Canadian judge upheld the deportation on Thursday of one of China's most wated figitives, calling him a "common criminal".

5. As for pictures of Mr. Strauss-Kahn in handcuffs, the French may see a famous politician treated like a common criminal.

6. He refused to wear the blue uniform of a common criminal, going naked or in underpants.

7. In most people's eyes she was nothing more than a common criminal.
19 de dic. de 2019 4:02
Comentarios · 7
8
I think Som’s answer may relate to British English. In American English, “notorious” means famous (i.e. well known) for something bad. A “common criminal” is an ordinary criminal with nothing special, as opposed to a celebrity criminal (a famous person who commits a crime), a super-criminal (like those faced by super-heroes), a notorious criminal, a Robin-Hood (steals from the rich and gives to the poor), a criminal genius, etc. “Common criminal” is a collocation, whereas “ordinary criminal” is merely an ad-hoc combination of an adjective and a noun. To call someone a common criminal is a huge insult, since it suggests that he is not even outstanding as a criminal.

19 de diciembre de 2019
2
I agree with Phil. In the US anyway (and speaking as a lawyer) people who are convicted of felonies or misdemeanors are frequently called „common criminals.“ it’s got nothing to do with misdemeanor vs. felony classification. A common criminal is not a legal phrase, but my perception of one would be that of a non-violent offender (a petty thief perhaps, embezzler) as opposed to say a rapist. You wouldn’t call a rapist a common criminal, you’d call him a violent offender.

An „ordinary criminal“ I suppose would be synonymous with a common criminal but I’ve only rarely heard that phrase used.

A notorious criminal would just be someone everyone has heard about, at least in one country anyway. In the US for example, Charlie Manson, a well-known murderer, was a notorious criminal because his name here was practically a household word. He garnered tremendous publicity over the last 50 years. In Germany, Andreas Baader and Ulrike Meinhof were notorious criminals in the 1970s because they were part of a terrorist organization, the RAF.
19 de diciembre de 2019
2
Phil's answer also applies to British English. A common criminal is a frequent offender who is not particularly famous, inventive or outstanding in the field of crime and is a collocation. A notorious criminal is famous for their crime. Perhaps Som's reply is more about Indian English, which is a major variety of English in its own right, and probably, in terms of numbers if speakers, the most common.
19 de diciembre de 2019
1
Precisely, Phil. As in "Sir Isaac Newton was famous for his scientific genius but also notorious for his unpleasant temperament".
19 de diciembre de 2019
1
There is no literal interpretation of this term because people often use it very loosely. In legal terms common crime can be:

1. A misdemeanor as opposed to a felony.
2. Crimes (arbitrarily) listed under common law.
3. Most frequently or commonly committed crimes.

Since even the legal definitions do not coincide, lay usage is even more arbitrary based on what an individual thinks a common criminal is.
19 de diciembre de 2019
Mostrar más