You’d have/You’d have had
Hi, there
Which of THESE sentences is right?
You’d have no way of knowing this, but I am allergic to peanuts”
or
“You’d have HAD no way of knowing this, but I am allergic to peanuts”?
Which of these two sentences is right?
Thank you very much!!
Busca entre varios profesores de Inglés...
Correcciones · 3
1
You’d have/You’d have had
Hi, there
Which of THESE sentences is right?
You’d have no way of knowing this, but I am allergic to peanuts”
or
“You’d have HAD no way of knowing this, but I am allergic to peanuts”?
Which of these two sentences is right?
Thank you very much!!
The first sentence is right.
1
Ok firstly : Which of these two sentences ARE correct. (sentence is in the plural) Don't make the same mistakes as the BBC.
You’d have/You’d have had
Hi, there
Which of THESE sentences is are right? Correct
You’d have no way of knowing this, but I am allergic to peanuts”
or
“You’d have HAD no way of knowing this, but I am allergic to peanuts”?
Which of these two sentences is are right?
Thank you very much!!
Both of them!
In the first sentence the context would have been a normal remark based upon some ignorance of the fact that you are allergic to peanuts. This is a present ongoing context.
The second remark would have been made within the context of an event having taken place, for example, peanuts were added to a meal and you became allergic, and the cook had no way of knowing this before hand. This would be said in the context of something in the past.
Context is all important here and it is very very difficult to predict the context, each situation would necessitate the correct response form a native English speaker but trying to explain this is very difficult.
0
You’d have/You’d have had
Hi, there
Which of THESE sentences is right?
You’d have no way of knowing this, but I am allergic to peanuts”
or
“You’d have HAD no way of knowing this, but I am allergic to peanuts”?
Which of these two sentences is right?
Thank you very much!!
Either is correct.
1 is more common now in current english. This is used more for informing someone you were allergic.
2 is an older way of speaking. It means that there is no way you could have known I was allergic to peanuts. And is or was commonly used in a situation where someone gives someone peanuts and did not know the other person was allergic. You are saying they would not have known if they were not told.
Now in current English sentence 1 is tended to be used for both scenarios.
¿Quieres avanzar más rápido?
¡Únete a esta comunidad de aprendizaje y prueba ejercicios gratuitos!
No pierdas la oportunidad de aprender un idioma desde la comodidad de tu casa. ¡Explora nuestra selección de profesores de idiomas con experiencia e inscríbete ya en tu primera clase!
Empieza a aprender hoy
