When I can use "lidir" and "lıdır"?
I got these sentences:
1. John Londralıdır
2. Maria Madridlidir
3. Peter ve Martha Berlinlidir
Anyone can please explain why those sentences have different ending?
When I can use "lidir" and when I can use "lıdır" ? Thanks.
Busca entre varios profesores de Inglés...
Respuestas · 18
2
Hello,
If the last vowel is "a" or "ı", our choice is "-lıdır" (LondrA-lı)
If the last vowel is "e" or "i", our choice should be "-lidir" (Madrİd-li)
If the last vowel is "o" or "u", our choice should be "-ludur" (TokyO-lu)
If the last vowel is "ö" or "ü", our choice should be "-lüdür" (ÜrgÜp-lü)
Also, these sentences would sound more natural as "John Londralı, Maria Madridli" without the part "-dır, dir, dur, dür"
We quite rarely need this "-dır" suffix in Turkish (especially while scientifically speaking)
Hope this is clear enough and helps!
1
It depends on the last vowel! :) I understand that "pure" Turkish words have consistent vowels, and any exceptions are usually from borrowed words.
The "ı" matches with "LondrA".
The "i" matches with "BerlIn" and "MadrId".
So... because I'm from Australia (Avustralya) and you're from Indonesia (Endonezya), do we use "lidir" or "lıdır"? :)
0
I have made this explanations tons of times but I don't give up since many sources teach the "-dir" suffix wrong. "-dir" is not a personal suffix. It has four tasks for the nouns: 1) official speech (that's why many sources present it as if it's the main personal suffix), 2)guess, 3)possibility, 4)generalisation. So those sentences must be "John Londralı." "Maria Madridli." "Peter ve Martha Berlinli". |||||||||| as for your question: you must have a main categorisation about the suffixes: the suffixes of -e/-a type and the suffixes of -ı/-i/-u/-ü type. (((((((Unfortunately this section of questioning&answering on Italki is not ideal. Everything seems complicated here. But i'm gonna give a try:
0
any exception? yes. there are. but their number aren't much. as an exception, they always take the suffixes with "e", "i" or "ü" though their last vowels don't fit the rule.
0
if the last vowel of the word is "ö/ü", you have to choose the suffix with "ü". ||| üzüntü: sorrow - üzüntülü: upset |||
¿No has encontrado las respuestas?
¡Escribe tus preguntas y deja que los hablantes nativos te ayuden!
No pierdas la oportunidad de aprender un idioma desde la comodidad de tu casa. ¡Explora nuestra selección de profesores de idiomas con experiencia e inscríbete ya en tu primera clase!
Empieza a aprender hoy
