多彩な 英語 講師陣から検索…
Russia flagAnna Pitinova
Grammar question Why was "WHICH" Instead of "THAT" used in this sentence? "Сapsaicin, the ingredient WHICH makes chillies hot, does not seem to have any addictive qualities whatsoever" Please, explain me!

訂正 · 4

0
First of all, your sentence needs commas around the phrase “the ingredient WHICH makes chillies hot”, because this phrase is non-restrictive, as it does not restrict the meaning of “capsaicin”. Capsaicin already has a meaning, so the phrase is just a reminder to readers who may have forgotten.

On the other hand, the phrase “which makes chillies hot” is a restrictive relative clause, as it serves to restrict and define the meaning of “the ingredient”, which otherwise would be unclear. 

When referring to things, we can use “which” to introduce both restrictive and non-restrictive relative clauses. Since your example is a restrictive relative clause (serving to define “the ingredient”), we could use “that” instead. In fact, I would definitely use “that” — it’s better style, as it makes it obvious that the clause is restrictive / defining.

So, “that” is better style, but “which” is the safer option if you’re not quite sure whether a clause is restrictive or not. Of course, you really should learn to recognize the difference, since this determines the proper use of commas. Assuming you know how to speak with proper prosodic rhythm, you can simply say the sentence out loud and notice where you pause — put commas there.

Let me know if my explanation helped you.
0
This video might be helpful: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2VfzEMKeoEk

もっと早く上達したいですか?

この学習コミュニティに参加して、無料の練習問題を試してください!

ご自宅で快適に語学を学べるチャンスをお見逃しなく。経験豊富な語学講師陣の中からお選びいただき、今すぐ最初のレッスンにお申し込みください!

今すぐ学習を始める