Position of the verb
Hi, everyone
Which of these sentences is right?
“I asked her what the biggest mistake that parents make in raising their children IS”
“I asked her what IS the biggest mistake that parents make in raising their children”
“I asked her what the biggest mistake IS that parents make in raising their children”
Thank you very much!!
多彩な 英語 講師陣から検索…
訂正 · 3
0
Different people will have a different preference here. I would say that they are all correct, but the smaller the gap between 'mistake' and 'is' the better. As a writer, I would go for the third option. Either can be said in conversation though because you get a way with a lot more when speaking. 'When' might work better than 'in' as well.
Other alternatives are:
I asked her: 'What's the biggest mistake that parents make when raising their children'. [More applicable to written form].
I asked her to name the biggest mistake that parents make when raising children. [Not great though]
It's a dificult sentence to resolve because it has four subjects - her, mistakes, parents, and children; and four actions - asked, make, is, and raising. There's a lot going on.
0
They're all fine, particularly in spoken English. The third is my favourite. The second is fine, but it reads like quoted speech, so it's more likely to be spoken than written. The first one is fine, but you make a very long noun phrase, so the reader/listener needs to remember all the information from “what” to “children is”. The third is best because you break it into two parts, making it easier on the listener / reader.
Edit: haha you've got two completely opposite answers!
0
Honestly, they're all correct. The third is my least favorite because it separates the subordinate ("that parents make in raising their children") from its pre-appositive. If you were writing this, you probably would use the second but also use quotations marks before "What" and at the end. If you're speaking informally, 1 or 2 are fine.
もっと早く上達したいですか?
この学習コミュニティに参加して、無料の練習問題を試してください!
ご自宅で快適に語学を学べるチャンスをお見逃しなく。経験豊富な語学講師陣の中からお選びいただき、今すぐ最初のレッスンにお申し込みください!
今すぐ学習を始める
