多彩な 英語 講師陣から検索…
Brazil flagGabriel
Question Hi, there Could you help me with one question? Do you say "The middle class is who most read The New York Times articles in the US" or "The middle class is who reads the most New York Times articles in the US"? Thank you!

訂正 · 5

0

Question

Hi, there

Could you help me with one question?

Do you say "The middle class is who most read The New York Times articles in the US" or "The middle class is who reads the most New York Times articles in the US"?

Thank you!


Hello,

It is the second, "The middle class is who reads the most New York Times articles in the U.S."

0

Question

Hi, there

Could you help me with one question?

Do you say "The middle class is who most read The New York Times articles in the US" or "The middle class is who reads the most New York Times articles in the US"?

Thank you!

-----

I think that neither sentence really sounds natural in English. I would say either


1. In the US, most of the people who read New York Times articles are middle class.

2a. In the US, those who read the most New York Times articles are the middle class.

2b. In the US, the people who read the most New York Times articles are the middle class.


As Robert mentioned, the sentences have two different meanings.


Sentence 1 means that of all the people who read the articles, the greatest number of them are middle class, e.g. if 100 people read an article, more than 50% of them will be middle class people.  

Sentence 2a and 2b both mean that middle class people read more articles than other classes of people; e.g. working class people read 100 articles each year, but middle class people read 200 articles each year. 


I hope this was not too confusing!

0
Your sentences have different meanings: This is if you mean to talk about the MOST PEOPLE: "It is mostly the the middle class who read The New York Times articles in the US" or "The New York Times articles are mostly ready by the middle class in the US" If you mean the MOST ARTICLES: "The middle class is who read the most New York Times articles in the US" or "The middle class is who reads the most New York Times articles in the US" (as you wrote) is correct
0

'read' is past tense (pronounced like "red")

'reads' is present tense

So technically they both can be correct but you'd never say either of those sentences you've written as the "is who most" is unnecessary. In real speech/writing you'd say:

"The middle class reads the most new york times articles in the US. "

or

"The middle class read the most new york times articles in the US" (which would indicate past tense; you'd tend to be referring to a year in the past) .

So you'd use this past tense read in real life more like : "The middle class read the most new york times articles in the US last year." or, preferably  "In the last year, it was the middle class that read the most new york times articles."

もっと早く上達したいですか?

この学習コミュニティに参加して、無料の練習問題を試してください!

ご自宅で快適に語学を学べるチャンスをお見逃しなく。経験豊富な語学講師陣の中からお選びいただき、今すぐ最初のレッスンにお申し込みください!

今すぐ学習を始める