多彩な 英語 講師陣から検索…
Juha
Could a person learn without studying any grammar? I wonder you guys opinion if an adult person could learn Italian without studying any grammar, and just by listening and picking up the language as he or she goes? How long would it take to be at a reasonable level if understanding and being understood? Has anybody done this as a second language?*of understanding

回答 · 13

1
I definitely think it's not possible: you can learn as you go just by reading and listening provided you have a minimum of basic grammar. You don't need to pull all-nighter hunkered down on grammar books as if you were about to take an exam, but the learning process of an adult is very different from the one of a child, so, even if it is just the very basic rules, you need at least a smattering of the grammar of the language you are going to learn. Moreover, to learn just the basic grammar it's not difficult at all and then, you will learn how to use the words even without knowing the rules, on this I agree. Many natives know exactly how to use many prepositions, tenses ect. but if you think about it, even though they are native, they attended a bit of lessons in school.
0
La grammatica è importante. Solo con l'ascolto non è completo.Per imparare perfettamente una lingua devi conoscere le basi grammaticali. Si devono seguire tutte le 4 aree d'apprendimento:scrivere,leggere, ascoltare, parlare. Ma senza una base grammaticale non sei completo perché non sai perché è dove sbagli.
0
I don't think you can master Italian in a reasonable amount of time without studying any grammar, There are some pretty difficoult verb coniugations that even Italian people sometime miss. although I know you can learn enough to make people understand you. A lot of people that migrate to Italy learn the language without studying it, so it is defenetly possiblle. if by learning you mean be able to communicate i would say: yes it is possible. If your goal is to master the language, instead, I would say: it'd take too long to understand the pattern of some verb coniugations and learn them p.s. I'm sorry if there are any mistake; still learning English
0
yes it's possible, I know a person that did that, but he is Spanish, and learnt Italian, I don't think that would have been possible between languages very different
0
In my opinion you can. if we see the reality, the 90% of the people in Italy have learned italian naturally and they have not made classical studyes the language spoken by the people is quite near the concept of the phrasal verbs or the idiomatic expression... is not so logic... it not depends really by rules you can put in a math equation... when you speak with a native people... english people... what do you like? the grammar? or you like it/you/he/she is funny... smart... easy...or what do you want? here you have the best asnwer... the real skills you need in the concept of communications... of course... yuo want to write a book... you are here for a work, well it' s more easy you need a good italian... in this case i can't say you a good italian is not important... different context... different skill... this is obvious... in this forum... i think workers are an exception... the most of the people are students or they are people have a carrer in the istruction/education... is not the entire world you find in a foreign country...

まだあなたの答えが見つかりませんか?

質問を書き留めて、ネイティブスピーカーに手伝ってもらいましょう!

ご自宅で快適に語学を学べるチャンスをお見逃しなく。経験豊富な語学講師陣の中からお選びいただき、今すぐ最初のレッスンにお申し込みください!

今すぐ学習を始める