whereismypen
Why use this tense? "If we don't hurry up the train will have been leaving before we get there." That example sentence is in my grammar book, which is to explain the future perfect continuous tense. But I'm confused. Normally, We use "if + present + future tense" if more proper than it? And " hurry up (...) the train" Is there anything else between them? thank you
2020年7月20日 09:48
回答 · 3
I agree, the sentence in your grammar book, as you have written looks incorrect.
2020年7月20日
"If we don't hurry up the train will have been leaving before we get there." This sentence is not actually correct. It should be: A) "If we don't hurry up the train will have left before we get there." (using the future conditional) OR B) "If we don't hurry up the train will leave before we get there." (using the future)
2020年7月20日
I agree. You could use "If we don't hurry up, the train will leave before we get there", or, less elegantly, "If we don't hurry up, the train will have left before we get there". But the choice in your example is horrible. I wonder if you need a different grammar book? This tense is little used. And the example the book gives is just silly. Oh, yes: you might well expect a comma after the "if" clause - "If we don't hurry up, the train ..." https://esllibrary.com/blog/future-perfect-vs-future-perfect-progressive https://ginsengenglish.com/blog/english-verb-tense-frequency
2020年7月20日
まだあなたの答えが見つかりませんか?
質問を書き留めて、ネイティブスピーカーに手伝ってもらいましょう!