Search from various Engels teachers...
Elia Murru
Why do you say estoy cansado instead of soy cansado to say I am tired?
My Spanish equals zero, but I would like to know the difference in usage between the verb estar and ser.
16 mrt. 2015 05:25
Antwoorden · 13
1
Differing ser from estar is a tough issue in Spanish. It needs some practice but there are a few main rules.
Estar is either used for describing the physical placement of someone or something (Lucía está en la calle Cervantes; los libros de Miguel están en su habitación) or to give a clue about how the person looks like, feels like etc at a precise moment (Estoy cansadísima esta tarde; ¿por qué está tan colorada Angela?).
When the person or object is normally this way, it´s their common feature, we use ser (Dolores es normalmente muy pálida pero hoy está colorada; mi carro es mercedes, es grande y rojo; soy polaca)
It´s a long and tricky topic, I´m pretty sure you´ll find a complete explanation in your language.
16 maart 2015
1
i think estoy is used when it's something temporary
16 maart 2015
I'm pretty new but this seems to be a common topic. It seems a simplified way to explain it is Estar is used more for something temporary or happening now. Ser is used with more permanence. So Estoy Cansado - I am (right now) tired. Soy Consado would be more that you are always tired or you are a tired person. of course there is gray area, but that seems to be the explanation to get started.
So Estoy aborrido means I am bored.
Soy aborrido means I am boring.
At least that is my understanding so far.
16 maart 2015
i'm tired = Estoy cansado
i am tired = Yo soy cansado
16 maart 2015
you use the verb ''estoy'' when you feel tired because you are not tired is how to say I am an engineer( you study for this) not born whith this.
The explication in spanich is:
Usas el verbo ''estoy'' para decir que tienes ese estado de animo, prabablemente por trabajar y utilizas ''soy'' cuando quieres decir que naciste con ello o conseguiste eso, por ejemplo al decir ''soy hombre(naces así)'' o al decir ''soy ingeniero(conseguiste esto por estudiar)''
Espero haberte ayudado ;)
4 april 2015
Meer weergeven
Heb je je antwoorden nog steeds niet gevonden?
Schrijf je vragen op en laat de moedertaalsprekers je helpen!
Elia Murru
Taalvaardigheden
Engels, Italiaans, Spaans
Taal die wordt geleerd
Engels, Spaans
Artikelen die je misschien ook leuk vindt

🎃 October Traditions: Halloween, Holidays, and Learning Portuguese
19 likes · 6 Opmerkingen

The Curious World of Silent Letters in English
16 likes · 11 Opmerkingen

5 Polite Ways to Say “No” at Work
22 likes · 7 Opmerkingen
Meer artikelen