Vind Engels Leerkrachten
JihyeB
'How long have you had it?' vs 'How long have you been having it?'
I like you car. How long (you/have) it?
In this sentence, the answer is 'have you had'.
But I wonder what if I use 'have you been having'?
I've learned 'have' cannot be use in a progressive like 'having'.
Is that the reason? or is there any reason cannot be answer? :(
14 jul. 2015 06:03
Antwoorden · 4
5
'Have' cannot be used in the continuous form when it means 'own' or 'possess'. So, you must say 'How long have you had (owned) your car?' 'Do you have a pet?' 'I have a lot of friends'. This is because 'have' with this meaning is a stative verb - it describes a state or condition.
'Have' can be simple or continuous when it is an active verb - it describes and action. This is seen in expressions such as 'have a coffee', 'have a good time', have a shower' and so on.
e.g. 'They are having dinner' - describes the action of eating. 'My neighbours are having a party' - describes the actions of dancing, listening to music, eating, drinking, etc.
14 juli 2015
3
how long have you had is correct.
You can use 'having', but not in this sentence. for example, 'how long have you been having these headaches?'; "We are having a party on Saturday". This could also be phrased as "We are going to have a party on Saturday".
I think she is having a nervous breakdown. I am having another cup of coffee before I go to work.
14 juli 2015
Heb je je antwoorden nog steeds niet gevonden?
Schrijf je vragen op en laat de moedertaalsprekers je helpen!
JihyeB
Taalvaardigheden
Engels, Japans, Koreaans
Taal die wordt geleerd
Artikelen die je misschien ook leuk vindt

6 Ways italki Can Help You Succeed in Your School Language Classes
6 likes · 0 Opmerkingen

The Power of Storytelling in Business Communication
46 likes · 12 Opmerkingen

Back-to-School English: 15 Must-Know Phrases for the Classroom
33 likes · 7 Opmerkingen
Meer artikelen