Search from various Engels teachers...
Евгения
지어야 하는 거지?
Can you help me with grammar in this sentence?
"왜 내가 집을 지어야 하는 거지?"
Is "어야" from the "어야지/아야지" construction? Why was 하다 necessary after it? And what is 는 거지?
19 feb. 2016 15:36
Antwoorden · 3
1
"왜 내가 집을 지어야 하는 거지?" == 왜 내가 집을 지어야 하는 것이지? => Why is it that I have to build a house?
* verb + (어/아)야: connective phrase expressing a required/expected condition.
- 사람은 먹어야(만) 산다: Human beings must eat to live. ("만" adds emphasis)
- 고생을 해 봐야(만) 인생을 안다: One must experience a hardship to know life.
* verb + (어/아)야 + 한다: 한다 (also 된다) here means "it will do", so the whole phrase just means "One must ... ".
- 나는 가야(만) 해 == 난 가야 돼: I must go. ("해" is not adding much, other than completing it with "it is required").
- 떠나야 할[하는] 그 사람: he who has to go.
- 너는 열심히 공부해야 해 [돼]: You must study hard.
- 너를 잊어야 한다면: if I had to forget you.
* 거지 = 것이지: -지 is a sentence ending for stating something softly or making a suggestion.
- 이렇게 하면 되는 거야: You do it like this and it will work. (a clear, firm statement)
- 이렇게 하면 되는 거지: same, but softer in tone, like partly talking to oneself.
- 이제 그만 가지?: Shall we go now? (a different usage making a suggestion)
(so ~지 ending here may be like ~거야? or a question to oneself, which is not clear without the context)
Here's some structures similar to ~(어/아)야 but meaning different things:
- 나는 가도 돼: I can [I am allowed] to go. ("도": also, as well). "해" won't work here.
- 나는 가면 돼: I can go and that will be it ("면": if ...). "해" won't work.
- 나는 가면 안 돼: I must not go. "해" won't work.
- 나는 가고는 해: I go from time to time. "돼" won't work here.
All these conjugations and particles are what make Korean very expressive as well as difficult to learn: 가야(만), 가도, 가면, 가서는, 가고는, 가기는, 가기만, 가기까지는, 가면서도, 가지는, ...
19 februari 2016
Heb je je antwoorden nog steeds niet gevonden?
Schrijf je vragen op en laat de moedertaalsprekers je helpen!
Евгения
Taalvaardigheden
Engels, Duits, Japans, Koreaans, Russisch
Taal die wordt geleerd
Duits, Koreaans
Artikelen die je misschien ook leuk vindt

Same Word, Different Meaning: American, British, and South African English
22 likes · 17 Opmerkingen

How to Sound Confident in English (Even When You’re Nervous)
17 likes · 12 Opmerkingen

Marketing Vocabulary and Phrases for Business English Learners
14 likes · 6 Opmerkingen
Meer artikelen
