Jade
"He is from Russia" or "He was from Russia"? Hey guys, I've got a kind of grammatical question. Say you are writing an essay about an experience you had 5 years ago during a trip when you met a Russian person named Jack, with whom you've lost contact (You didn't add him on Facebook nor did you ask for his phone number). Now when you write about Jack in your essay, would you write "Jack is from Russia" or "Jack was from Russia"? Thanks!
28 aug. 2016 16:28
Antwoorden · 7
2
This is a question of style, not a question of grammar. As a matter of style, the answer depends on your approach to the essay and the tone you want to adopt. Let's suppose that you want to begin the essay with one of these sentences. "Jack is from Russia" brings him into the present, and can be perfectly fine even if you haven't seen him in five years. "Jack was from Russia" puts him decidedly in the past. Style, not grammar.
28 augustus 2016
He is from Russia. If then (5 years ago) he lived in Russia, in your story he will be always "He is from Russia".
28 augustus 2016
Heb je je antwoorden nog steeds niet gevonden?
Schrijf je vragen op en laat de moedertaalsprekers je helpen!