JAP_70
Why is it "it's" instead of "they're"? What do all drone bees have in common? Are they all males, females, worker bees, or carpenter bees? Well, the queen and worker bees are all females, it's the drones who are all males. Thanks in advance for your help.
25 mrt. 2017 17:38
Antwoorden · 14
1
This is the way I understand it: “It” is here a so-called “dummy subject”. It doesn’t mean anything, but is a necessary part of the sentence. Compare with this: Question: “Did you see where John and Jenny went?” Answer: “Look, it’s them over there.”
25 maart 2017
1
The last part is not quite right, but the interesting question is how we should correct it. "Well, the queen and worker bees are all females. It's the drones who are all males." (It's better as two sentences) Can we correct the last sentence as "They're the drones ..." as you mentioned? No, we can't. "they" normally refer to something that has already appeared, so what is it referring to here? It can't be "the queen and worker bees" since they are not males, and it can't mean the carpenter bees either. What's left is the drone bees, but it will make the sentence "The drone bees are the drones ...", which makes no sense. I believe what the speaker meant is: It's the drones THAT are all males. This is a common "it ... that" emphatic sentence pattern. "It" is just a placeholder that has no meaning. You can use it whenever you need to emphasize a specific part of a sentence. For example: - Money matters => It's money that matters" (title of an old song) - I love your honest above all => It is your honesty that I love above all. - I do this with a great pleasure => It is with a great pleasure that I do this. The speaker meant "Drones are all males", but since he wanted to contrast them against the queens and workers, he employed the emphatic pattern, but made a mistake doing that. The "it ... that" pattern doesn't allow other pronouns in place of "that" as far as I know. Note that there are sentences that might appear like the emphatic pattern but actually are not. E.g. It's the Smiths, who are our neighbors! (the speaker has just spotted them) The "it" here is not a placeholder but a pronoun referring to "what I see in front of me", and the phrase is not the emphatic pattern but a relative pronoun compound sentence. "who are ..." just modifies "the Smiths", with no special emphasis.
25 maart 2017
The answer is incorrect. Q: What do drone bees have in common? A: They are all males. To answer your question, words such as he/she or it are singular pronouns and "they" is used for plural.
25 maart 2017
I forgot to add the link of the video and transcript where appears the questions. http://edition.cnn.com/2017/01/05/studentnews/ten-content-fri/index.html In the minute 3:50 starts the trivia. The next time I am going to give more context and data. I really appreaciate your help.
25 maart 2017
Heb je je antwoorden nog steeds niet gevonden?
Schrijf je vragen op en laat de moedertaalsprekers je helpen!