Yuri Kim
は、には、とは、では…の違いを教えてください
31 jan. 2018 00:17
Antwoorden · 2
2
This is a tough and interesting question. I'll explain radically. *** What is 'は'? (it does't indicate subject) 私はAKIです。(I am AKI) 私がAKIです。(I am AKI) Two sentences look like same.but gramatical structures are completely different. ------------------------------------------------------ *** 私がAKIです。(I am AKI) Very roughly saying, the structure is like this: 私が(I as subject) AKI (AKI as object) です (am as verb) OK, let's suppose '~が' is subject. ------------------------------------------------------ *** 私はAKIです。(Me, it's AKI) 私は is not subject. if you regard ~は as subject, you cannot explain the following sentences. - 「象は鼻が長い」(The elephant has a long nose) which is subject, 象? 鼻?  - What's your order? -> 「僕はコーヒー」    (hey, you are a human, not coffee !) - 「あいつは殺す」   this means, in 98% case, "I/We'll kill him" very rarely means "He kills" ※ if you say「あいつが殺す」, this 100% always means "He kills" - 「男は度胸、女は愛嬌」   means: "it's important for men to have courage, for woman, loveliness.", but Men __is not__ courage. Men is creatures and courage is a state of mind. ------------------------------------------------------ *** Then What is 'は'? One of the functions of 'は' is 「提題」"to raise the theme/issue of the sentence/conversation". Clumsily saying, it means "talking about" - 「象は鼻が長い」 -> Talking about the elephant, it has a long nose - 「僕はコーヒー」 -> Talking about me, it's coffee (I'll order a cup of coffee) - 「あいつは殺す」 -> Talking about him, it's to kill (I/We will kill him) - 「私はAKIです」 -> Talking about me, it's AKI(My name is AKI) +++ 応用(application) 「僕はコーヒー、あいつは紅茶」    -> Talking about me, it's coffee. And him, it's tea. 「あいつは殺すが、お前は生かす」    -> Talking about him, it's to kill. But you, it's to let live. 「私はAKIで、彼はKIM」    -> Talking about me, it's AKI. And him, it's KIM 「男は度胸、女は愛嬌」    -> Talking about men, it's courage, while women,loveliness. (to be continued)
31 januari 2018
Heb je je antwoorden nog steeds niet gevonden?
Schrijf je vragen op en laat de moedertaalsprekers je helpen!