Sasha
Professionele leerkracht
This is the house that/where I lived in for many years as a child. Hello! In a test question the key says "that". "This is the house that/where I lived in for many years as a child." This must be a mistake, isn't it? If it's not a mistake could you explain to me why I can't say 'where'. Thank you!
2 apr. 2020 19:07
Antwoorden · 4
3
You can say This is the house that I lived in This is the house where I lived You would not say “this is the house where I lived in.”
2 april 2020
2
Underlying statement: I lived in this house for many years as a child. "This house" is the object of the preposition "in." "In this house" is an prepositional phrase which acts as an adverb of location for the verb "lived." Cleft statement: This is the house that I lived in for many years as a child. "That" is a relative pronoun for "the house" and is the object of the preposition "in." "the house that ... in" is a prepositional phrase that functions as an adverb of location for the verb "lived." Alternate statement: I lived here for many years as a child. "Here" is an adverb of location for the verb "lived." Alternate cleft statements: 1 - Here is where I lived for many years as a child. "Where" is a pronoun for "here" which is an adverb of location for the verb "lived." 2 - Here is / This is the house where I lived for many years as a child. "The house where" acts as an adverb of location for the verb "lived."
2 april 2020
2
If you are talking about location you can use where, but if you are referring to the house as a thing you would use which or that.
2 april 2020
правильно that потому что lived in если бы было просто lived тогда where
2 april 2020
Heb je je antwoorden nog steeds niet gevonden?
Schrijf je vragen op en laat de moedertaalsprekers je helpen!