"Joe Sixpack" is a very average fellow; whose commonness is summed up as one who drinks beer as opposed to fine wine. The term can be used in discussions of demographics and marketing: "This advertisement [or political speech] may appeal to doctors, attorneys, and professors, but how will it appear to Joe Sixpack?"
Your quote comes from a description of an American-born Muslim cleric. The news story is pointing out that, although a Muslim (which many Americans find unfamiliar and exotic), the cleric engaged in activities normal to Americans (fishing, silly investments) and used American slang (as opposed to reading ancient prayers) in his sermons. In short, he appeared to be part of, and in harmony with, American culture, increasing the contrast to his later activities.