Search from various angielski teachers...
Darya
Good day!
I came across the sentence "The hall was empty, servants having long gone home or sleeping in their quarters" and what bothers me here is "servants having long home"
I'd say "the hall was empty, servants have long gone home".
I see it as a perfect form of gerund, but isn't it supposed to describe some action? Like "Servants having long gone home left the hall empty". The way it's been used in the original sentence just leaves it to be uncomplete.
Do I miss something about usage of perfect gerund? Would it sound natural to use "servants have gone home"?
11 mar 2022 09:03
Odpowiedzi · 3
2
This is a participle rather than a gerund.
'having long gone home' means 'because the servants had long gone home'
Without using a participle clause, it would be:
"The hall was empty because the servants had long gone home or were sleeping in their quarters"
You should do a web search for 'relative and participle clauses' if you'd like to learn more about it.
It's a difficult topic but it's very interestiing)
11 marca 2022
1
The original sentence is ok as the use of gerund is for phrases. As I am not an English teacher, I am not sure about the exact grammar point.
If you wish to change it, it will be:
.... servants have long gone home or are sleeping in their quarters ....
11 marca 2022
Nadal nie znalazłeś/łaś odpowiedzi?
Napisz swoje pytania i pozwól, aby rodzimi użytkownicy języka ci pomogli!
Darya
Znajomość języków
angielski, francuski, rosyjski
Język do nauczenia się
francuski
Artykuły, które również mogą ci się spodobać

Same Word, Different Meaning: American, British, and South African English
22 głosy poparcia · 17 Komentarze

How to Sound Confident in English (Even When You’re Nervous)
17 głosy poparcia · 12 Komentarze

Marketing Vocabulary and Phrases for Business English Learners
14 głosy poparcia · 6 Komentarze
Więcej artykułów
