Could anyone plz explain this sentence? I couldn't get the meaning of it.

▪ I couldn’t have my friend celebrate his 15th birthday without him.

Question

Could anyone plz explain this sentence? I couldn't get the meaning of it.

▪ I couldn’t have my friend celebrate his 15th birthday without him.

Answer

There isn't much context, but I read it as three different people: "I", "my friend" and "him". Let's call "my friend" Tom, and "him" David to make it less confusing.

So: I couldn't have/let/allow Tom celebrate his (own) birthday without David (also being present).

Or, if the context is different, it could be David's birthday.
So: I couldn't have Tom celebrate David's birthday without David (also being present).

So as you can see, just using pronouns is confusing. Normally, the identities are established earlier, but when you have two people, both using "he/him" pronouns, talked about in a single sentence, it can become confusing unless one writes very carefully.

Answer

I agree with the others . . . if HIM refers to MY FRIEND it doesn't make sense.

Answer

It would make sense if 'him' was replaced with 'me'.

Answer

Hi evryone i need to someone help me to learn English thanks

Nie przegap okazji, by nauczyć się języka w zaciszu własnego domu. Przejrzyj naszą ofertę doświadczonych korepetytorów i zapisz się na pierwszą lekcję już teraz!