Szukaj różnych nauczycieli angielski...
Ukraine flagVolodymyr
مشكله مع قراية مرحبا. من قريب انا ابتديت اتعلم مصري. بحب اللغة دي اوي، بس عندي مشكله. طلا ما هي لغة متكلمة، مش لاقي حاجه اقرا.

Poprawki · 16

0
Actually, regarding the last comment, many languages have the same alphabet. For example Spanish, English, French, etc... They are definitely different languages although they have the same alphabet. I personally have no problem calling a local dialect a language. Language just refers to what people use to communicate with. Even sign language is a language. The local spoken language in Egypt is an Arabic dialect. And if a dialect becomes very different from the original language that it came from, eventually it becomes a new separate language altogether. Where is the fine line? I think it is not worth arguing over.
0
I understand Volodymyr. As a general rule, for a 'dialect' to fall into a 'language' category, it must have a different alphabet, but since Arabic has only one alphabet, any spoken accent or written dialect that uses Arabic alphabet is considered just a branch of the main source which is the Arabic language. Regarding Wikipedia articles, I came across many mistakes in them in the past few years. I wasn't sure that I'm right in my assumption about Wikipedia pages until lately when I knew that anyone could write Wikipedia articles or edit them, and not necessarily someone with the right education or experience. So to be honest with you I no longer trust Wikipedia or see it as a reliable source.
0
Hi Mumtaz. I didn't take any offence. Nor did I mean any. If it's usually called a dialect, I'll call it a dialect as well. No problem. I called Masri a language just because I once read an article on Wikipedia about Egyptian Arbic which said "Egyptians know the dialect as the Egyptian colloquial language (اللغة المصرية العامية [elˈloɣæ l.mɑsˤˈɾejjɑ l.ʕæmˈmejjæ]) or Egyptian dialect (اللهجة المصرية [elˈlæhɡæ l.mɑsˤˈɾejjɑ]; abbreviated: مصري‎ [ˈmɑsˤɾi] "Egyptian"). However, it is also named the Modern Egyptian Language (اللغة المصرية الحديثة‎, IPA: [elˈloɣæ l.mɑsˤˈɾejjɑ l.ħæˈdiːsæ])". That's it.
0
It's not about offending anyone, but it's wrong to call a dialect (language) or vice versa because it shows lack of knowledge. It has nothing to do with tastes :) A language means something, and accent/ dialect means something else, it's as simple as that and I was surprised that no one even corrected you before me. If you on the other hand were offended that I corrected you, then by all means call it whatever you want, yet get used to be corrected on italki because this is what we do here; correct each other when learning each other's languages. I meant well because this is a language learning website/ forum and again I wish you good luck.
0
في كتب العاملة بس مش كتير 
ممكن تدور في جوجل  " كتب بالعامية المصرية " 
وتنزل الي يناسبك

Chcesz robić postępy szybciej?

Dołącz do społeczności uczących się i wypróbuj darmowe ćwiczenia!

Nie przegap okazji, by nauczyć się języka w zaciszu własnego domu. Przejrzyj naszą ofertę doświadczonych korepetytorów i zapisz się na pierwszą lekcję już teraz!

Zacznij naukę już dziś