Szukaj różnych nauczycieli angielski...
South Korea flagKuno
How can I figure this out ? This is about the modal verb "should." A. What is Jane doing now ? She should have arrived here an hour ago. (It was advisable for Jane to arrive an hour ago, but she didn't and still hasn't arrived. And the speaker expected Jane to arrive an hour ago.) B. You shouldn't have talked about Susan when Tom was with us. You know, Tom and Susan broke up recently. (It was advisable for the one being spoken to not to talk about Susan, but he or she did it.) C. I cannot conclude this preface without lamenting that an early and untimely death should have prevented Persius from giving a more finished appearance to his works. (This does not mean the early and untimely death did not prevent Persius from giving a more finished appearance to his works, right ?) In this context, the author died early and could no longer make his works better, and therefore the speaker feels sad, and this is what I think the modal verb "should" implies. I think I'm missing some important point about should. Help me.

Odpowiedzi · 4

1
C. I cannot conclude this preface without lamenting that an early and untimely death should have prevented Persius from giving a more finished appearance to his works. (This does not mean the early and untimely death did not prevent Persius from giving a more finished appearance to his works, right ?) Form of present perfect has/have + past participle We use the Present Perfect to say that an action happened at an unspecified time before now. The exact time is not important. Also the word "should" is also used as the past tense for "shall" Should is not being used as a modal to give advise. Therefore the writer is lamenting the fact that Persius died before giving a more finished appearance to his works. I hope this helps.
1
You understood A and B perfectly, as I'm sure you're aware. C is tricky because the way it's used is archaic and obsolete. In this old-fashioned form, "should have" means "probably," but the speaker cannot say for certain. "Born in 1802, Percius should have missed the turn-of-the-century." (Because few born in 1802 lived to 100 years, Percius is unlikely to have lived into the 1900s, but there is always a possibility he did.) There is another meaning that you didn't type down, and that's "if." "Should he be so foolish, his position will soon be vacant." (If he is truly that dumb, he won't hold his position of power for long.)
0
Should can be used to -give advice or make recommendations -talk about obligation -talk about probability and expectation . A. What is Jane doing now ? She should have arrived here an hour ago. (We expected her to arrive an hour ago, but she didn't and she still hasn't arrived.) B. You have the correct idea. C. The construction SHOULD HAVE + PAST PARTICIPLE is also used for expressing regret. "To regret" = To feel sorry, disappointed, or distressed about. “To lament” here means “to regret very much.” I cannot conclude this preface without lamenting that an early and untimely death should have prevented Persius from giving a more finished appearance to his works. I regret that it should have happened. I regret that an early and untimely death should have prevented Persius from giving a more finished appearance to his works. I should have studied harder in school.
0
"Should" is also the past form of "shall". That's your missing point. The other missing point is that subjunctive (hypothetical) actions can be expressed in past tense. This gives a sense of formality and/or politesse.

Nadal nie znalazłeś/łaś odpowiedzi?

Napisz swoje pytania i pozwól, aby rodzimi użytkownicy języka ci pomogli!

Nie przegap okazji, by nauczyć się języka w zaciszu własnego domu. Przejrzyj naszą ofertę doświadczonych korepetytorów i zapisz się na pierwszą lekcję już teraz!

Zacznij naukę już dziś