Szukaj różnych nauczycieli angielski...
Panama flagHemant
How to put indirect objects after some verbs? Some verbs can follow with indirect objects without preposition. Examples I gave her a pencil. I bought Ana some apples But why are others incorrect if preposition is not added I talked to her yesterday I ate with Ana spicy dishes. (NOT: I ate Ana spicy dishes) I run with him the 15K marathon (WHY NOT I run him the 15K marathon)

Odpowiedzi · 3

1
"with Ana" is not an indirect object but a "prepositional phrase" (just a phrase starting with a preposition). An indirect object usually involves the preposition "to" or "for" understood but not actually said or written . Only a few verbs take indirect objects; most do not. If the sentence makes sense using "to" or "for" you may be able to use the indirect object . So: "I bought the child a toy" could also be said "I bought a toy for the child". "I gave my student an answer" could also be said, "I gave an answer to my student". In the second form each time the indirect object is converted into a prepositional phrase however, the reverse if not true. MOST prepositional phrases cannot be converted into indirect objects. I hope I have not complicated things for you. [Could NOT say, "I hope I have not you complicated things"]
0
"I ate with Ana spicy dishes. (NOT: I ate Ana spicy dishes) I run with him the 15K marathon (WHY NOT I run him the 15K marathon)" In this case, it would be more natural to say "I ate spicy dishes *with Ana*" and "I ran the 15k marathon *with him*". When you rearrange the sentences like this, you can see that there is only one object of the verb in each sentence (and it is direct). You ate *spicy dishes* and you ran *the 15k marathon*. Both of those are complete sentences in and of themselves. "With Ana" and "with him" are what is called a prepositional phrase and are not indirect objects of the verbs "eat" and "run". Prepositional phrases will be attached to other, full sentences and are composed of the preposition and its object. In this case "Ana" and "him" are the objects of the preposition "with", meaning who you did the action alongside. This is why you can't leave out "with"; you would have an object not linked to anything else. In your first example, "I gave her a pencil" you have both a direct object - "a pencil" - and an indirect object - "her". "Her" in this sentence is an indirect object of "to give" and not part of a prepositional phrase. Thus, you do not need a preposition. However, I have to note that you can also say "I gave a pencil to her". In this case "to her" forms a prepositional phrase. Saying "I gave a pencil her" would be incorrect. The sentence can be arranged this way because "to give" can take either a direct object *and* and indirect object (i.e: "I gave her a pencil") or can be phrased with a direct object and a prepositional phrase (i.e: "I gave a pencil to her"). Verbs like "to eat" and "to run" cannot take indirect objects and so you have to form it with a prepositional phrase. I hope this helps and I explained it clearly.

Nadal nie znalazłeś/łaś odpowiedzi?

Napisz swoje pytania i pozwól, aby rodzimi użytkownicy języka ci pomogli!

Nie przegap okazji, by nauczyć się języka w zaciszu własnego domu. Przejrzyj naszą ofertę doświadczonych korepetytorów i zapisz się na pierwszą lekcję już teraz!

Zacznij naukę już dziś