Szukaj różnych nauczycieli angielski...
Israel flagGeriLektor ze społeczności
Using only past simple when talking about the past English students tend to use only past simple when they are talking about the past, because they are not sure which tense is the correct one: He told me he arrived a day earlier (instead of he had arrived) When I entered the room he talked by the phone (instead of he was talking) I worked in this company for the last 10 years (instead of I've been working) Those sentences sound very bad? Not the best but acceptable? sound OK?

Odpowiedzi · 4

2
Actually, we can get away with using the past simple most of the time, even if there is a better alternative available. Only your 2nd sentence is a real problem, because the past simple means that he started talking on the phone immediately after you entered. If he was already talking on the phone, we need the past progressive. The same is true in the past and in the present — actions (not states) in progress require the progressive / continuous aspect. The 1st sentence is acceptable. Yes, technically, we’re supposed to backshift with reported speech, but if the meaning is clear and the situation hasn’t changed, then we don’t always do so. Your sentence works either way. Some don't; you'll get a feel for it eventually. The 3rd sentence is wrong, but you could easily get away with it in casual conversation. With verbs that describe a person’s main activity (work, study, live), it’s usually OK to use the present perfect simple instead of the present perfect continuous. It should be “I’ve worked”, but the “‘ve” is often elided in rapid speech, and “worked” can be taken as either the simple past or the past participle. Here’s a 4th one for you: “I’m not hungry; I just ate.” That should be “I’ve just eaten”, but Americans often use the simple past instead of the present perfect *when referring to something that was completed in the past*. This is perfectly fine for colloquial American English, although British speakers usually use the present perfect when no time in the past is specified and there is a strong connection to the present. Number 5: The past with “used to” is often useful for indicating past habitual actions or states, but it’s always OK to use the simple present instead. As far as the past with “would” (with dynamic verbs only, as a synonym of “used to”), you should learn to recognize it, but you really never *need* to use it yourself.
1
Actually, in South Africa and the UK, we would understand you. If you want to speak like a native, of course, you would use the correct tense. However, most people are forgiving and do understand you. You would have to say: When I entered the room, he was talking on the phone.
0
Actually, we can get away with using the past simple most of the time, even if there is a better alternative available.

Nadal nie znalazłeś/łaś odpowiedzi?

Napisz swoje pytania i pozwól, aby rodzimi użytkownicy języka ci pomogli!

Nie przegap okazji, by nauczyć się języka w zaciszu własnego domu. Przejrzyj naszą ofertę doświadczonych korepetytorów i zapisz się na pierwszą lekcję już teraz!

Zacznij naukę już dziś