搜尋自 英語 {1} 教師……
Mihaela
Which one is correct?
'How often do you go shopping?' she asked her.
Reported speech:
1. She asked her how often she went shopping.
2. She asked her how often she goes shopping.
2013年2月7日 16:02
解答 · 13
1
The correct answer is number 1.
"How often do you go shopping?" she asked her.
She asked her how often she went shopping.
When you use reported speech you back-shift the tenses, following the rule of "true at the time it was said". This is much easier to understand than trying to work out if the situation is still true at the present moment.
2013年2月7日
I have used both, but I agree that number 1 is more correct. The change in tense isn't really supposed to be context-sensitive. You just change the tense; it isn't supposed to make sense, it's just the language.
He said he liked reggae. I thought you said you were sick. You said you knew the answer.
Look up the phrase "asked if I was American", for instance, on Google; it's very common, and being American or not isn't usually temporary. Or "You said you loved me."
"She asked her how often she goes shopping" sounds utterly ridiculous if the conversation took place 150 years ago!
2013年2月11日
Number 2 as per Peachy.
2013年2月7日
The correct answer would be # 2.
She is asking her in a more present way how often she goes shopping. However, to ask her how often she "went" would be referring to how often she went shopping in the past.
Hope that helps.
2013年2月7日
I'd like to help you, but I barely speak in English and I'm working at my pronunciation, too. I'm not a native speaker, maybe someone from USA, UK or Australia would like to have a chat with you. Good luck! :)
2013年3月15日
顯示更多內容
還沒找到你要的答案嗎?
寫下你的問題,讓母語者來幫助你!
Mihaela
語言能力
阿拉伯語 (馬格里布), 英語, 法語, 義大利語, 羅馬尼亞語, 俄語
學習語言
阿拉伯語 (馬格里布), 英語, 法語, 義大利語, 俄語
你也許會喜歡的文章

Same Word, Different Meaning: American, British, and South African English
12 讚 · 11 留言

How to Sound Confident in English (Even When You’re Nervous)
13 讚 · 11 留言

Marketing Vocabulary and Phrases for Business English Learners
11 讚 · 6 留言
更多文章