尋找適合你的 英語 教師……
Alexey
except and besides
A situation: Someone knows something that nobody knows. So, I have got two variants to say about it:
1) nobody knows except him
2) nobody knows besides him
And a question is: which version is correct? Or maybe both are wrong?
2014年10月10日 07:36
解答 · 5
2
They are both right but the first is more natural and commonly used.
2014年10月10日
1
Both of these sentences make sense.
'Except' is perhaps not the best word to use here, as it suggests some kind of exclusion. It's not incorrect, though.
'Besides' suggests 'in addition to'.
However, to me the most natural way to say this would be:
Nobody knows apart from him.
2014年10月10日
1
It's more natural to say "Nobody knows but him." or "Only he knows."
In your sentences, though, both are correct. Just be careful, because the meanins CAN be different. These days, 'besides' is mostly used to begin a sentence that gives additional, but unrelated, information about a previous subject. For example:
A: Do you want to go a baseball game this weekend?
B: I can't make it, I have to study for a test. Besides, I don't like baseball.
In that case, it has a meaning like 'also'. 'Except' cannot be used in that situation. Similarly, you could (rudely) answer by saying:
B: I would, except that I don't like baseball.
Here, 'except' has a meaning similar to 'but'. You cannot use 'besides' in this situation.
You are right to be confused about these two words, but in your example, the meaning is the same.
2014年10月10日
還沒找到你要的答案嗎？
寫下你的問題，讓母語者來幫助你！
