Navegante Linear
Is this sentence correct? The professor keeps copies of his previous student’s thesis.
2017年9月12日 23:53
解答 · 2
1
It is grammatically correct, but is it what you mean? You use 'student' and 'thesis' in the singular, so you are referring to one student. For a professor to have only one previous graduate student would be unusual. Not impossible, but unusual. You also use 'copies' in the plural, so you are saying that he has multiple copies of the same thesis. Again, unusual, not impossible, but unusual.
2017年9月13日
Grammatically : yes. Logically: no I agree with Gary ( in fact, I find that I always agree with what Gary says...). The grammar - in itself - is fine, but it's hard to imagine a situation in which you would say this. The present simple 'keeps' suggests that this is the professor's regular habit. But I have trouble seeing how a professor can make a regular habit of keeping multiple copies of a single thesis written by one individual student. This doesn't make a lot of sense. An equally correct but far more likely version of this sentence would be this: "The professor keeps copies of his previous students' theses." This means that the professor always keeps copies of the theses (plural) written by his students (plural). As something which the professor does on a regular basis, this makes far more sense.
2017年9月13日
還沒找到你要的答案嗎?
寫下你的問題,讓母語者來幫助你!
Navegante Linear
語言能力
阿拉伯語, 加泰隆尼亞語, 英語, 法語, 德語, 義大利語, 葡萄牙語, 西班牙語
學習語言
阿拉伯語, 加泰隆尼亞語, 英語, 法語, 德語, 西班牙語