[已刪除]
Is Cantonese and mandarin the same? Cause I was listening to the Jackie Chan version of ILL MAKE A MAN OUT OF YOU. And he sings great but on two of the videos it said Cantonese version and the other one said mandarin version. So im guessing they are the same??? but just wan to make sure
2010年1月11日 02:58
解答 · 5
Jackie Chan is Cantonese, his wife is Taiwanese (speak mandarin). They has been together for a long time. I assume Jackie Chan speak and sing perfect Cantonese and Mardarin. The pronounciation between the Cantonese and Mandarin is not the same, some characters has to be changed to match the melodies. So, the meaning and/or wording in that song is not 100% compatible.
2010年1月14日
they r not the same,mandarin is chinese offical language,and mandarin is sort of dialect.
2010年1月11日
Hey nicole, guess what? Your question could be fully answered here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cantonese_(Yue) And I guess the term "mutually unintelligible" in that article (between cantonese and mandarin speaker) explains a lot.
2010年1月11日
hi, hi nicole, I believe that aside from having a difference with the vocab, they also differ with the tones. Cantonese has 6 tones while Mandarin has 4. The writing system (chinese character) is the same though. :)
2010年1月11日
Cantonese is one of the dialects of Chinese. Cantonese only has a spoken form which is different from Mandarin Chinese. Its writing form is also the same Chinese characters. Now many people are learning Mandarin Chinese.
2010年1月11日
還沒找到你要的答案嗎?
寫下你的問題,讓母語者來幫助你!