Wählen Sie aus verschiedenen Englisch Lehrkräften für ...
Aurelio
-ます form before から: sometimes, never?

Dear all,

as far as I know, から normally follows the plain form when it means "because" and you leave it to the second half of the sentence to set the level of politeness. But I have found several books for beginners which have you form sentences like this:

(1) ちょうど向かいに二十階のビルが立っていますから、なにもみえません。「Assimil]

(2) あ、雨が降ってきましたから、地下鉄にのりましょう。[Assimil]

(3) 私は中国語が少しできますから、おともしましょうか。[Assimil]

(4) 必ず行きますから、待っててください。[Assimil]

(5) 今週の土曜日に浅草でお祭りがありますから、スミスさんは加藤さんと浅草にいきます。[Japanese for busy people]

(6) [talking about a restaurant]: ええ、時々来ます。美味しいですから。[Japanese for busy people]

So, question for the native speakers: do all of these sound natural to you? Would you say it like this - or differently? Does it depend on the situation - or are some of these gaijin textbook phrases only (5 sounds particularly strange to me) ;-) Thanks much in advance!

Aurelio



Kommentare · 3

1

All of the "から" parts at least sound natural to me.

> から normally follows the plain form when it means "because"

So, did you think that "(1)...いるから. (2)...きたから", etc? "This also works and just sounds a little more casual.

BTY, から and ので can be interchangeable and may change the politeness and/or nuance as in Kazuko's comment. The general explanation I found says that から is subjective and ので is objective.

Hope this helps.

1

As a native Japanese speaker, the first half of each sentences sounds natural to me when you would be polite. But each of whole sentences doesn't sound so natural to me. When I say something like them, I will say as follows.

(1)真向かいに二十階のビルが建っていますから、何も見えないでしょう。

(2)あ、雨が降ってきたから、地下鉄に乗りましょう。

(3)私は、中国語が少しできるので、おともしましょうか。

(5) 今週の土曜日に浅草でお祭りがありますから、スミスさんは加藤さんと浅草に行くと思います。or 行くでしょう。

(4) and (6) have no problem.

Sometimes I feel examples in Japanese textbooks for foreign people are too polite to be natural.


0

Dear both, thank you for your comments, this is very helpful!

@Kazuko: thanks for taking the trouble to rewrite my sentences. Interesting to see the subtle variations. That textbooks are often too polite to make you sound natural was exactly my suspicion.

@Jun: yes, I had in my head that it had to be いる, きた, etc. when coming before から. I understand now that this is not a hard & fast rule but rather a question of style.

I had been afraid that it might be objectively wrong and only to make things "easier" for foreigners - I once even saw an army language course that simply omitted all は、を、が to - supposedly - keep it simple (!) Good to know that this case is different :-).

Best regards,

Aurelio

Verpassen Sie nicht die Gelegenheit, bequem von zu Hause aus eine Sprache zu lernen. Stöbern Sie in unserer Auswahl an erfahrenen Sprachlehrern und melden Sie sich jetzt zu Ihrer ersten Unterrichtsstunde an!

Heute mit dem Lernen beginnen