Yo C
Is it acceptable if I start a sentence with "but"?
I read some sentences in an essay of a friend this morning. She wrote <em>"I was born and raised in Ha Giang, which is a mountainous area, so since I was a child, I've thought of leaving for a big city</em><em> </em><em>But</em><em> when I get older, I don't think about living in a big city anymore. I want to live in a peaceful countryside." </em>

In my personal opinion, "but" is a conjunction that connects 2 clauses in a sentence.

For example:
<ul><li>I can't play the piano but I can play the guitar.</li></ul>
Or:
<ul><li>She doesn't care about anything but money.</li></ul>

In the case above, Instead of writing "<em>But</em><em> when I get older,.." ,</em> I would write <em>"However when I get older,..." . </em>

I am really not sure about my opinion, that's why I am here to have your help.

Thank you in advance ^^
4. Juli 2020 04:03
Kommentare · 5
3
I agree with Abdalá. But then again, what do I know?
4. Juli 2020
3
It’s perfectly fine to start a sentence with a conjunction, and most grammar guides permit it. The belief that it’s not okay is a result of teachers making up their own rules. Instead of teaching when it’s acceptable to start a sentence with a conjunction, they taught an overgeneralized rule. It’s just lazy teaching. See here: <a href="https://www.quickanddirtytips.com/education/grammar/can-i-start-a-sentence-with-a-conjunction" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">https://www.quickanddirtytips.com/education/grammar/can-i-start-a-sentence-with-a-conjunction</a>;
4. Juli 2020
1
Thank you so much for your very clear explanation, Adam S.
You know what, whenver I saw people writing "but" at the begining of a sentence, I immediately told them to change it into "however". Then, there're still many people who continue using "but'' in that way, I start wondering myself if it is okay to use "but" like that...
I am still looking forward to knowing the opinions of other people on italki.com to have my own conclusion.
Thank you one more time, Adam.


4. Juli 2020
1
This is an area where people have some different opinions. Some have been taught to never use but at the beginning of a sentence. But, when the author want to highlight the "but," it can be effective when used to start a sentence. "However" is generally more acceptable at the beginning, but since it is basically a synonym for "but," it arguably raises the same issue as "but," which is that, as you point out, it is a conjunction. That said, some might think that "however" when used at the start of a sentence is a bit awkward, but "but" is nice and crisp. This is sort of a case of some authors choosing to break the "rules" for more effective communication. The same can be said for starting a sentence with "and." It should be done sparingly no matter what, but it can be effective in some occasional instances, even though it is not really proper.
4. Juli 2020
Yay! Thank you so much, Abdalá. I am reading the information from the link you send me ^^
4. Juli 2020