Wählen Sie aus verschiedenen Englisch Lehrkräften für ...
Iran flagHamed
A Migration Hypothesis about Edmontosaurs An article states that there is a migration hypothesis which explains the way edmontosaurs, a kind of dinosaur lived in arctic areas, survive during harsh winter in Alaska’s North Slope and provides three arguments to support the hypothesis. A professor, on the other hand, elaborates on the fact that the reasons provided are not compelling and refutes each of author’s points. First, the article claims that there were no plants growing during harsh North Slop winter and as edmontosaurs only fed on plants, so they had to migrate to warmer areas. The professor rebuts this claim by mentioning that the edmontosaurs could nourish from dead plants. According to her, during summer there was 24 hours sunshine in arctic areas in which provided a favorable condition for plants to grow well, and in turn, these dead plants during winter would be a good source of food. Furthermore, the author posits that some archeological evidences reveal that edmontosaurs lived in herd which shows another reason for migration of them because it helps animals coordinate their migration. However, the lecturer states that living in herd does not mean that they have migration life and this behavior had to with a kind of strategy to provide them a protection from predators. She also gives an example of especial elks in this regard living in herd in a forest without having any migration. Finally, the article points out that physical condition of edmontosaurs obviously shows that they were capable of migrating long distances even in a harsh condition of arctic winters. The professor also casts doubt on this point by explaining that even though edmontosaurs had a decent physical condition to migrate for a long distance, their offspring especially juveniles did not have such physical condition to survive during harsh winter in a long migration.

Korrekturen · 2

1

A Migration Hypothesis about Edmontosaurs

An article states that there is a migration hypothesis which explains the way edmontosaurs, a kind of dinosaur lived in arctic areas, survive during harsh winter in Alaska’s North Slope and provides three arguments to support the hypothesis. A professor, on the other hand, elaborates on the fact that the reasons provided are not compelling and refutes each of author’s points.


First, the article claims that there were no plants growing during harsh North Slop winter and as edmontosaurs only fed on plants, so they had to migrate to warmer areas. The professor rebuts this claim by mentioning that the edmontosaurs could nourish from dead plants. According to her, during summer there was were 24 hours of (<< you can say 24-hour sunshine, turning the phrase "24 hours" into a hyphenated adjective, but I think "24 hours of sunshine sounds better for more formal writing) sunshine in arctic areas in which provided a favorable condition for plants to grow well, and in turn, these dead plants during winter would be a good source of food.


Furthermore, the author posits that some archaeological (<< spelling/not sure if this was British English difference) evidences reveal that edmontosaurs lived in herds (<< you could say they "lived in herds" or were "herd animals") which shows another reason for their migration of them (<< made this sound more natural) because it (<< a bit confusing; what does the pronoun "it" refer to here?) helps animals coordinate their migration patterns (<< we typically talk about their "migration pattern" in this context; "migration" is a bit more general and refers to the concept of migrating rather than the specific way in which the animals migrate.). However, the lecturer states that living in herds does not mean that they (<< avoid overuse of pronouns; use nouns instead of pronouns where possible) have migration life and this behavior had to with a kind of strategy to provide them a protection from predators. She also gives an example of especial elks in this regard living in herds in a forest without having any set migration patterns.


Finally, the article points out that physical condition of edmontosaurs obviously shows that they were capable of migrating long distances even in a the harsh conditions of arctic winters. The professor also casts doubt on this point by explaining that even though edmontosaurs had a were in decent physical condition to migrate for a long distance, their offspring especially juveniles did not have such physical condition to survive were not capable of surviving during the harsh winters in during a long migration (<< I've rewritten the latter part of this sentence to be more concise and natural).


Great writing! It is especially difficult to write at an academic level, but your vocabulary words were very appropriate for the context (e.g. "to posit"). I have tweaked just a few things to make the wording sound a bit more natural.

Möchten Sie schneller voran kommen?

Treten Sie dieser Lern-Community bei und testen Sie kostenlose Übungen!

Verpassen Sie nicht die Gelegenheit, bequem von zu Hause aus eine Sprache zu lernen. Stöbern Sie in unserer Auswahl an erfahrenen Sprachlehrern und melden Sie sich jetzt zu Ihrer ersten Unterrichtsstunde an!

Heute mit dem Lernen beginnen