which one of the following sentences is (are) correct? In case of there being a wrong sentence, why is it incorrect?
1. “For the study, participants learned a task where they had to recognize a hidden pattern in the questions they were asked.”
2. “For the study, participants learned a task that they had to recognize a hidden pattern in the questions they were asked.”

Question

which one of the following sentences is (are) correct? In case of there being a wrong sentence, why is it incorrect?
	1.	“For the study, participants learned a task where they had to recognize a hidden pattern in the questions they were asked.”
	2.	“For the study, participants learned a task that they had to recognize a hidden pattern in the questions they were asked.”

Answer

Where is correct.

Learned seems a strange word here. Some of them might not have learned it. More normal is “the participants were set a task…”

Answer

Only the first one is correct.

In the second one, the relative pronoun "that" is replacing "task" in the dependent clause. "That" is the subject of the clause. When a relative pronoun is the subject of a clause, you can't follow it with a subject pronoun. You could say "...a task that required them to recognize..."

You could also just divide it into two sentences.

For the study, participants learned a task. They had to recognize a hidden pattern in the questions they were asked.

Verpassen Sie nicht die Gelegenheit, bequem von zu Hause aus eine Sprache zu lernen. Stöbern Sie in unserer Auswahl an erfahrenen Sprachlehrern und melden Sie sich jetzt zu Ihrer ersten Unterrichtsstunde an!